Am I a Palestinian?????

Show all answers

Blue Footsâ„¢

All Palesintians before 1948 were JEWS.

After 1948, they all of a sudden became Arabs.

Amazing.

I guess YOU ARE a Palestinian Jewish Girl. :)

Anonymous

I am Palestinian because my parents, grandparents, great grandparents, all the way back...were Palestinians. I take no pride in being an American....the true pride is knowing deep inside i am a true Palestinan. my family dates back and back.

kismet

Yes you are; just as my mother is (born before 1948) and just like me (born long after 1948). My grandparents told me that in Europe, the non-Jews spit at them and yelled "go back to Palestine!".
I suppose this makes us all Palestinians....

sweet

yes you are , be proud of the truth
Jews can be from any nationality like every one in the world

You are a Palestinian Jew (or simply, a Jew).

harajuku lover

yes you are palestinian. i know a woman that is czechislovakian however you spell it. but you are still jewish. i guess you could say you are israeli too. your own choice.

younis q

I SEE A LITTLE CHANCE TO SAY
IS THE TIME OF PEACE GET START UP
IN THE HOLLY LAND (HISTORIC PALESTINE)
DO YOU AGREE TO NAME THE NEW STATE BY " THE HOLLY LAND STATE " IN WHICH INCLUDE ALL PALESTINIANS AND ISRAELIS.
PLEASE VOTE FOR THE NEW STATE.

Noor

you are a Palestinina Jew.
Jews lived in Palestine along with Muslims and Christians.

For thousands of years there was no such conflict. In the 19th century the land of Palestine was inhabited by a multicultural population of Palestinian Arabs â€“ approximately 86 percent Muslim, 10 percent Christian, and 4 percent Jewish. For centuries these groups had lived in harmony.
untill Zionests came.

read more
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/history/

read what they did to Orthodox Jews in Jerusalem who refused (and still refuse) to recognize the existence or authority of the so-called "State of Israel"

Over the years, a number of Neturei Karta activists and followers settled outside of Palestine. Some of the reasons that these individuals abandoned the country in which they and their families had lived for many generations (having lived there many years prior to the establishment of the illegitimate so-called "State of Israel") include; ideological refusal to live under the illegitimate heretical "Israeli" regime, them being exiled by the Zionist government for their insistence of remaining independent of the illegitimate heretical regime or them being unable to live a normal family life due to them and their families being persistently harassed, repeatedly incarcerated and many times even physically tortured by the Zionist police and agents.
http://www.nkusa.org/aboutus/index.cfm

Kevin S

Hey hey what's with the russian comment. Russians and jews whos great grandparents lived in Russia are two different things. Russian jews born in palestine were palestinian too. Ever notice how many israelis look middle eastern but have last name likes rabinovitz......its because they are actually jews, unlike the 1.5 million russians that roam israel today

What did you tell them to put on your passport. That's what you really think you are.

THE TRUTH IS HOLY

I guess that you are a Palestinian. You should actually list that when you fill out applications for schools, jobs, etc. It might help. Good luck and I thank you for an enlightening question. B'Hatzlacha.

d-rizzle

If you see yourself as an Arab Jew, then I would say Yes. Very interesting situation

J Q Public

No unless you were born in Palestine prior to 1948. Many older Israelis including some of their leaders were born in Palestine though.

lady_aya_84

Interesting.

What constitutes a "Palestinian" has changed since the creation of Israel. I'd say no. You are obviously proudly Jewish and no Palestinian would consider you one of them.

My mother's family are Mizrahi Jews born in what is now Israel, but formerly called Palestine. My father is 100% full-blooded Arab Palestinian. I love that and I always have -- and have always considered myself Palestinian even though I'm Israeli-born to a Jewish mum.

I'd honestly have to say if you are pro-Israel you are NOT Palestinian.

I have no doubt that if you deviate from the general opinion inside Israel, they tell you that you aren't Israeli and call you a Pali. Don't let them make you have a complex. You aren't a Pali, trust me.

Duane

No. You are an illegal European immigrant,probably from Russian stock.

Bravo Sierra

I ignore your roots, but yes you are Palestinians, if you still have documents of your birth event, keep it and give it to your kids cause Palestine will be back soon.

Citizen for a Just Peace

No. The Palestinian Territories are still under illegal occupation; they cannot establish the de jure sate of Palestine until they have control over their territory. Only when the government is established may you apply for citizenship. Since your postings are snide and infantile I assume your "question" is rhetorical. Whether it is or isn't I would recommend relocation. 22.5 % of historical Palestine is merely a starting point.

sparkle

it is still,and always will be PALESTINE,nothing former about it!

Bosco

No. You are descended from a pack of Russian atheists who came into Palestine under British auspices and seized power at the end of the Mandate,basing their "territorial" claim on the laughable idea that they were "descended" from an ancient people known as hebrews,of which no historian makes mention until the Roman conquest; they inhabited a small city-sate and subsequently died out. Basically,you are an illegal alien and an unwanted presence.

zion no more

No, you are not Palestinian; because you have no empathy for Palestinian people.

No, you are not a Jew; because you shun Jewish belief for zionism.

naserq22

I will let my Turkish friend answer you
"It was in Istanbul we were sitting on a table mixture of people an English man sitting next to me "
My Turkish friend looked at him in the eye and asked
Are you foreigner ?Angrily the English man looked at him
"NO I AM ENGLISH"
(of course in Turkey he was a foreigner,but he do not understand it, neither would you)
so are you Palestinian?

[ ImpaKt ]

Im pretty sure, you're not Palestinian.
It's written all over you!

A zion for sure but not Palestinian.

Let me put it this way;
Are you having a hellish life?
Does those idiots stop you every single day on check points?
Do you feel your rights is being ignored?
Has any member of your family taken away from you and put in camps or shut point blank or used as human shield?
Is your house been bulldozed by these murderers?
Are you constantly being harassed for no particular reason?

If you say YES to the above Que.'s,
you definitely are a proud Palestinian.

If NOT, you better stick with jews. For that's who you're!

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: