
JayJay
|
no they can't coz the israelis will always treat the Palestinians as a second class citizens ! the israelis think that they are superior to other humans! that's sad, I pity them. |
|

Zeno
|
Not after the crimes of Zion are summed up; the total is overwhelming. It would be like a negotiated settlement with the Third Reich. This is a gang of mass-murderers,not a nation still less a government. In any event they would never share power with Palestinians. No. Keep the horizon clear. There is no longer any room for compromise; the zionist monster must go.
That is the only hope for peace. |
|

gabriel m
|
If only they could... |
|

Sam
 |
wow for the black haired chick with the hateful comment there.
i have a message for you!
I DONT HAVE THE URGE TO KILL YOU ! lmoa, sure i don't agree of how Israel does things but not all Muslims want to kill you only the ones you piss off and kill their kids want to kill you XD
frankly speaking if you kill one of my family members il be darn pissed of too! wouldn't you be pissed off if an Arab killed you mom?
and secondly that land belonged to the Arabs sure it belong to you LONG TIME AGO but you don't see the Italians claiming back theire Holy Roman Empire now do you?
as for the main question. NO it wouldn't work there is to much revenge and hostility between the 2 factions it will never work someone has leave its the only way to live in peace. if Israel comes with a peace offering and reconstructs home and gives the Palestinians a chance and excuses for its mistakes the Arab people might say. "wow they aren't as much as an Asshole as we thought" but then again there is to much hate and revenge so it might not work out. |
|

*dodo* Palestinian and PROUD!!
|
nope....becuz after wht the israelis did to the palestinians they would never accept them in their land...... lemme ask u this....what are they gonna call the land?? thats the first problem right there.... |
|

Crystal (PSM)
|
I am in favor of a one state solution. Why should the Palestinians give up something for which they've sacrificed so much. |
|

michael w
 |
How can Jerusalem be a capital to the Palestinians when Israel are bulldozing down their homes with the excuse that they want to build a perk there. Its odd that not one Jewish home has ever been demolished in that city Why ? . I guess that says it all. Israelis do not want any arabs in "their" capitol |
|

michelle
|
If the situation was approached in like this 60 years ago, and houses and if land was not sold by crooked owners. Then the Palestinian people would never have had a reason to resist the European Jews from moving in. If they could have just brought what was really available to live on, then they could have made their way to the better spots gradually. Without moving Palestinians to the camps.
Jew and Muslims lived in peace in Palestine before the Europeans moved in.
I found some really nice videos on some history of Palestine before Israel and shortly after Israel. The last video is a song sang by many from many countries in honor of Palestinians, with pictures that are forgotten by many.
Hamas did not exist in those days, so what excuses did Israel have then? This is the reason the Palestinians are Terrorist.
If i lived their life, i would be a terrorist too. Braking the salience. Silence is what it is. We are shielded from this information. |
|

Yoni A
 |
This concept didn't work for Czechoslovakia, Belgium and the rest of the world.
I'm afraid that it would never work in such a fragile place such as our country. |
|

Freedomisthekey
|
Michelle are you calling Palestinians Terorists? They are innocent people. |
|

yanar89
 |
No, thats impossible.. Who is going to rule that place then?? If it was the Palestinians, it wont be a Jewish state, and the Zionists will surely make a riot, massacre more people and do other atrocious acts..
On the other hand, its gonna be an apartheid state if the Zionists were to be the leader.. Which isnt fair for the Palestinians.. So, they will do anything to regain their rights.. |
|

dandyl
 |
Well in Israel there are many Arabs who live very peacefully with the Jews and are very happy.Jerusalem will always be Israels capital,it will never change.Been that way for obver 3000 years,With regards to forming one big state with the Palestinians, that will never work, Given the historical mistreatment of minorities, especially Jews, in Arab lands, this idea would be a recipe for the persecution of Jews (and Christians).One proponent of the idea of a one state state suggested that an international force would protect the Jews, but no leader would entrust the fate of the Jewish people to such an unreliable guarantor. More important, if advocates of 1 one state acknowledge that Jews would need protection in such a state, what is the basis for believing this is a solution to the conflict? |
|

Kevin S
 |
If the Greeks and Turks Could not..........then Israelis and Arabs def. cannot. If 2 people do not get a long, don't force them. |
|

Emasculated Britain
 |
No, because it would effectively be a Jewish state with a permanent Jewish majority, so democracy, or at least "majority rule" democracy would not work. It would permanently exclude the Palestinians from power in their own country. It would need some kind of power sharing executive. Even though this would include everyone, it would still leave the minority marginalised, and alienate their community.
The one state solution is a good idea. So long as it does not include the Israelis. |
|

P. Sword
|
we did accept the jews among us and sheltered them, they stabbed us in the back, but it was our fault, who would hold a snake in his chest! the only way for god to full fill his promise to the jews is when they full fill their promise to him; that's to accept all of his prophets, including jesus and mohammad! but then, they well stop being jews!
gaththafi, the Libyan leader is funny, he calls it: isratine!
no, we'll not hold the snake in our chests again! |
|

The First Dragon
 |
Both Israelis and Palestinians live in one state (Israel) and have the same capital, Jerusalem. Israel does have a significant Arab population, you know; and one of its official languages is Arabic.
It depends entirely on the willingness of those who are to live together.
I think, though, that a majority of people in West Bank and Gaza are not willing to live in one state with Israelis. |
|

Clyde N
 |
After the Israelis killed so many Arabs to steal(NO ENUMERATION) their land and CONTINUE doing so-they would never want to see a MAJORITY Arab country-THAT IS WHY THEY ARE BUILDING ILLEGAL JEWISH ONLY SETTLEMENTS, bulldozing Palestinian homes and killing the owners.If they annex the West Bank and Gaza strips, Israel would INSTANTLY BECOME A MAJORITY ARAB COUNTRY, which it will anyway, in less than 30 years. The must implement Phase II-the Nazi Israeli Arab solution-Gas chambers? or kill them all looking for non existent terrorists under the guise of national security.They want a Jewish MAJORITY country and can only do so by eliminating the Arabs-the Israelis will not do so oherwise.
The following link gives some UNBIASED statistics on deaths on BOTH sides-see whom has the right to protect themselves from whom-it sure isn't the Israelis:
http://www.ifamericansknew.org/ |
|

jd
 |
They already are, if you are thinking of moving more in then I think you are a little behind the times. Not going to happen. |
|

Teresa (SFECU) -†- pray4revival
 |
Jews and Arabs already live together in one state and Jerusalem is their capital. 23.6% of Israel are Arab-Israeli citizens.
The problem is with the Arabs/Egyptians/Syrians that refused to accept a democratic government in 1948, who suddenly started calling themselves "Palestinians" in 1967, and have demanded yet another Arab country to go along with the other 22 in the Middle East where they can once again force the Jews to live as dhimmi, pay the extortion tax required by Islam, and dictate to them how and where they can live, what they can own, and how they can practice their faith. This is how it was before the Jews were given back their homeland (The Holy Land) so they could be self governing again. This is also how it is today for the few Jews that have been allowed to remain in any Arab country since 1948.
Today these Arab-Palestinians claim that was "living in peace"?? The only thing peaceful about it was their expectation that the Jews would live in peaceful submission to Islamic rule.
So the 1 state solution is absolutely out of the question. |
|

NYC Chutzpah
|
NO NO NO If the Muslims had to carve out their own state from India and call it Pakistan, why should the Jews give up their own viable state to include a bunch of people who have done very very little good for themselves in over 60 years. |
|

Sabrina
 |
NEVER!!!!
WHY GIVE LAND TO THE "PALESTINIANS" WHEN IT NEVER WAS THEIRS TO BEGIN WITH!??!?!?!?!?!
and even if we did give part of jerusalem to them it would still not be enough...IT WILL NEVER BE ENOUGH UNTIL ALL THE JEWS ARE DEAD!
Get it!? Muslims don't care for the land, they would rather have all the Jews dead in the world!
Nice, nice,....very peace loving indeed.... |
|

 |
|
|

| |
|