Do you think the land of israel was given to the jews from GOD?

Show all answers

RedRose (got headache)

funny - it's like (kazzabo el kizbe wo sadda2oha)
no God would never give palestinian lands for those killers

J Q Public

No,God is not in the real estate business.

Well that depends, do you think the Brits are GOD?

Freedom F

I don't think anyone believes that, just a few nutters on the periphery.

The occupation of Palestine is just plain greed.

EDIT
For example, look at the guy below me.

Edit Baddy Baddy Gorilla

Only in zion, can a contemporary story, understood to be a joke; be accepted as historical fact.

Brynn

Nope,Lord James Rothschild paid a lot of money to the Ottomans to get permission for the first "aliyah". It's always been money...money...and more money. Oh yes,that and people from Pittsburg using fake OT-sounding pseudonyms. That helped put a religious gloss on a state founded by atheists.

Bosco

It was given to all the people of the Book,meaning the Abrahamic faiths if you want to look at it religiously. It obviously should be relieved of the zionist government and be governed by a multicultural democracy. Basically I agree with Dalia.

tamarindwalk

No.

mark

The question is which Jews are we talking about . The Zionists secularist, communist ,atheists, colonist who violated all kind of God laws.

frangul

what do you think there would be to fight over if there wasn't religion?

Ola

No i don't think that and as a prove jews were all over the world not concentrated in Palestinian as they are now and i am sure that GOD don't accept what is happening to Palestinians now

Sam Jack

Only if god lives in Brooklyn or Paris, Bonn or Moscow.
Israel is a european gift to rid itself of more Jews.

dalia

i dont belive god did,but i think its a holly land for them,as it is for other 2 religions,so it doesnt belong to them exclusivly,it belong to muslims and christians as well.
btw B,i like ur answer haha funny!!

steppenwolf1a2003

No...1948 the UN gave it to them.

Mimi-מימי- ميمي

As a muslim, I don't and don't have to believe in the bible. I consider the bible a book that was changed by a Jew to serve his and his people's needs. They didn't only change their bible, but the christian bible as well to gain allies.
For me G-d is not a real estate.
G-d is Just and he wouldn't give happeness to some people on behalf of saddness of others.
I am sure that G-d is not happy with what the zionists did and still do. Even if the land is rightfully theirs they are not supposed to kick the people who lived in it this way. humilate the rest all the time, kill them, and treat them like animals.

Peace

Maya

No. You are are asking us to accept the idea that a tiny ethnic group worshiping a volcano picked up a land-grant from a supreme being and this is binding on all of humanity. It's preposterous. No one even takes it seriously except orthodox jews and fundamentalist christians.

Zeno

I agree with the report of President Wilson's 1919 commission on Palestine. The idea is utterly devoid of reason and "does not merit serious discussion".

Mike L

No god didn't, they just historically settled there after escaping Egypt though this all based on bible so the facts are scratchy

Yes, God did. God revealed one, and only one religion. Throughout time, man continues to branch away from this one religion, however it still remains, the completion of this religion is Islam. Islam believes in all the Prophets and Messengers of God; Abraham, Moses, David, Jesus, etc. If God gave the Jews Israel then he gave it to the people of the religion he sent down to Earth (Islam). Although, over time, people become corrupt, distort truths, and branch out from the straight path. But during the crusades, the Muslim people still shared, and were willing to share and allow safe passage through Jerusalem for the Christians and Jews, and it was the Christians who wanted it for themselves alone. Therefore you can't use the phrase "God gave Israel to the Jews" to justify the Israeli occupation of Palestine, because those are not even the original Jews, they strayed from the truth, and distorted the religion, thus leading the Christians into the same predicament.

Nastrodamos

Yes it was before my time, long before my time.

I did predict they will be living there all the time.

B

GOD WORKS IN MYSTERIOUS WAYS.

loco903

i no its true. it says in the torah. the palastinians stole it, we won it back, they stole it , and we keep on winning it back. we will always win it back

Michael J

I think at one point in history the land of Israel was given to the Jews by God (circa Joshua), while it was promised to the Jews for all time (circa Abraham). However, the current manifestation of the Jewish state was not neccessarily given by God, i.e. Israel does not draw its legitimacy from any divine promise. While Israel's detractors are fond of declaring that an ancient divine pledge has no bearing on us, they miss the point entirely. Israel was created legitimately, triumphed legitimately and its continued existence is legitimate, with or without any religious importance.

samsproudmommy

yes, how else can you explain how we are still here?

MikeInRI

Yes I do.

Good Luck!!!

stan46

yes

kismet

Yes.
It is in the bible.

Sarah

I sure do. Thats God's land. And people are trying to take it but you watch and see. God's not gonna let that happen. They'll get their land back.

JeCanGirl :)

yes, the bible proves its true.

Baddy Baddy Gorilla

Yes.

Allan M writes a libelous accusation.

A story would help explain. The Prime Minister of Israel sits down with the dead terrorist Arafat at the beginning of negotiations regarding the resolution of the conflict. The Prime Minister requests that he be allowed to begin with a story. Arafat replies, "Of course."

The Prime Minister begins his story: "Years before the Israelites came to the Promised Land and settled here, Moses led them for 40 years through the desert. The Israelites began complaining that they were thirsty and, lo and behold, a miracle occurred and a stream appeared before them. They drank their fill and then decided to take advantage of the stream to do some bathing--including Moses. When Moses came out of the water, he found that all his clothing was missing.

"Who took my clothes?" Moses asked those around him.

"It was the Palestinians," replied the Israelites--"

"Wait a minute," objected Arafat immediately, "there were no Palestinians during the time of Moses!"

"All right," replies the Prime Minister, "Now that we've got that settled, let's begin our negotiations."

samsoomathemadruba

Yes, is this a trick question ??

Annt Hu DeShalit

Of course.

Someone writes that the Jews took it from the Palestinians. Very cute!

The asker has it exactly backwards. The Arab league had no intention of establishing a Palestinian Arab state.

The area the Jewish national home was established in was then known as Palestine, and the Jews who settled there were accordingly known as Palestinians. Until 1948, the present Israel Philharmonic was the Palestine Orchestra, the Jerusalem Post the Palestine Post, and so on.

Palestine was never a country, but a somewhat vaguely defined geographical area. No occupying power ever made it an independent state, or established a capital in Jerusalem. Under the Ottoman Empire, it was part of the vilayet, or province, of Syria. The Arabs of Palestine had no historical, national or cultural identity distinct from other Arabs of the region. The term "Palestinian" never carried its present meaning until the 1960s, even for Arabs.

Arabs even denied that there was any such country as Palestine. During various deliberations about what was to become of "Palestine" after the Mandate, conducted by British and international commissions and other bodies, culminating with the United Nations in 1947, Arab officials, spokesmen and writers expressed their views on "Palestine." "There is no such country as Palestine. "Palestine' is a term the Zionists invented. . . . Our country was for centuries part of Syria. 'Palestine' is alien to us. It is the Zionists who introduced it." Local Arab leader to British Peel Commission, 1937.

"There is no such thing as Palestine in history, absolutely not," Professor Philip Hitti, leading Arab historian: to Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry, 1946. And later: "It is common knowledge that Palestine is nothing but southern Syria." Ahmed Shukeiry, later founding chairman of the PLO, to United Nations Security Council, 1956.

"Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity serves only tactical purposes The founding of a Palestinian state is a new tool in the continuing battle against Israel." Zuheir Muhsin, late Military Department head of the PLO and member of its Executive Council. Dutch daily Trouw, March 1977.

Abu Mazen is continuing the great Arafat tradition. But while Arafat stole billions from his own people, so far Abu Mazen has stolen only 100 million dollars.

But give him a chance; he will not do anything for his people either, except rob them blind.

.

peter k

Try to understand this, The land of Israel was given to gods people, Which include the so called 10 lost tribes of Israel, Israel is the world not that little country in the middle east which only came into being in 1948 and is occupied by one of the tribes of Israel namely the tribe of Judah the descendants of the other Tribes are United Kingdom Where the Queen herself is a direct descendant of King David, other are US, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, That is why these countries Ruled the earth, They ruled by the hand of God who allowed them to, This time is now coming to an end and quite soon you will see this turmoil like has never existed since the creation of the world, All the Banks will crash A great Atomic war will rage US will completely collapse Soon you won't be worried about Israel. Believe me "The end is Nigh"

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: