Does saying Israel doesn't exist magically make it not exist?

Show all answers

Lupines supports GEERT WILDERS

Only works if they tap their heels three times and Pray towards Oz. I think they forgot that part.

The modern state of Israel is 60 years old and counting.

Regarding this Philistine/Palestine thing and making other people disappear, that was never an israel intent. there is no co-relation between modern day palestinians and the ancient philistines. simply put, they are arabs. there is no modern state of palestine today. the palestinians of today are a fabrication of arab extremists to gain more israel land.

Anyone that believes otherwise has succombed to anti-Israel propaganda:

In an interview with the Dutch newspaper "Dagblad de Verdieping Trouw", March 31, 1977, PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein stated:

"The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel.

â€˜Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people. Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa - while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem.â€™

So why does he talk about Jordan? Out of all the arab nations why Jordan? Becaues Jordan was supposed to be the "palestinians" home state.

for deprogramming on this anti-israel propaganda, view here:
http://www.terrorismawareness.org/what-really-happened/

Ms.Miche

Hi Pazit,

I am noticing that those people are really running out of ideas now, and have resorted to really lame, fictitious and repetitive stories in order to prove their point. You can clearly see that the only ones that are left are the ones who have multiple accounts who are desperately fighting and losing.

You can see even in Y!A that Israel is taking over the Israel category. Those who have blocked us "talk amongst themselves" and "pat each other on the back."

Wait until you see what is in store for them in the next few months....

As always, Israel will prevail!

Sincerely,

Ms. Miche ; })

dandyl

israel is here to stay and will be around forever and ever.it gets stronger by the day.
by saying it does not exist, makes israel stronger, ironic, isnt it!!!
am israel chai

Morgan S

What a great Question..Denial is a Malady..People with this Malady cause incredible distress for all those around them..Denial is an element of Insanity..To say Israel does not exist..is simply Insane...I'm not a Jew, nor a Christian, I belong to no Religion, but Thank G-d!..I am Sane.

vansemmanuel

Only in the mind of those who say such a thing

Why so cynical?

Apparently, in the minds of some people, it does.

Angel SA

Magically, maybe; but in reality NO.

GOD BLESS!

PaperbackWriter JPAA

Yes! Did you not get that memo?

So you don't know that every time someone in this forum bashes Israel, Israel *VANISHES* - POOF! Just gone. And a hole appears in the middle east. A TINY hole, naturally, given that Israel is roughly the size of New Jersey or Wales, for Brits. (cue roll of eyes)

Honestly, I think some people here think that REALLY DOES happen when they tell their lies. Doesn't it bother them to swerve SO FAR from the FACTS?

Apparently not.

Bored Now

No, and neither do the apocalyptic posts saying its time is soon coming to an end magically make Israel disappear in the future. The wishful thinking of the hatemongers is just that.

future_jewish_public_defender

The thing about saying Palestine doesn't exist is that there is some truth to it. There has never been a Palestinian state and there is not one currently. Israel is an actual state that exists. Now, if the Palestinians were to have a state and it were to be formed legally, then hey... by all means, Palestine will be an existing country.

Feivel JPAA

It would sure seem many people think so, doesn't it. I wonder if we say other countries don't exist if they magically won't. Let me try. Nope. They are still there. Just doesn't work at all. LOL

Hyder

Well, I believe you're referring to the position held by most Muslim countries. Borders and maps are created by people. They're merely referring to maps rather than Israel as a society or culture.

But lets not forget that it's a place with people, their families and children... all as human as any of you. By saying Israel does not exist, they're denying the presence of the state of Israel and not meaning that there's a hole in the Middle East.

Before attempting to flame me thinking I'm an Israeli, know this, I'm a Muslim, not an Arab but just as Muslim!

The same holds for the state of Palestine!

Benjamin T

Jews obviously have a justification for the state of Israel to exist, religiously, ethoncintristically, historically, and the fact that it is recognized iternationally by the U.N., I believe that it should exist as a state. However, looking at it from an American(born catholic named Benjamin) perspective, and that means looking at the situation from all perspectives objectively, I believe that there should also exist the state of Palestein, and a third state of Benjamin(Just a coincedence that my name is Benjamin). Borders would need to be redrawn, however, The state of Palestein should be roughly the same size as Israel, and the state of Benjamin should sit between the two, encompassing the Holy City of Jeruseleam. If you read your Torah and Bible then you should know that this was the case originally and thats another reason why I suggest it be the solution. The state wont be a soveriegn state like the soverign states of Israel and Palestein. It will be a state such as an American state, however it will be shared by both countries. It will be a single united state in which the people who live in that state will give their tax money to their own state of Benjamin. The capital will be Jeruselem and both states will give tax money to Benjamin because of its size. The state of Benjamin will only be larger enough to encompass the holy city and its suburbs, unlike its historical predecessor. Therefore it will need support, and their will be competition for support, and if the wealthy Jews and the wealthy Muslims do not want to support, im sure it would hypothetically have no problem collecting support form christian America. Some Muslims like to say that they are people of "The Book." From their perspective, the Jews srayed from The Book or the right path, so therefore when god said that land was granted to them, them meant the people of The Book" therefore they strayed and the land shall not be theirs, and since it is internationally viewed as the converse, muslims see it as their land was stolen by infedels. However, some jews do believe that Jesus is/was a prophet and that they claim to be Jews because the apocalypse hasn't yet happened, and the anti-christ has came and been beaten, then Jesus hasn't yet fulfilled the prophesey, and therefore, isn't the messhiah......yet, so they claim to be Messianic Jewish. Therefore form a christian point of view its still too soon(with repect to the apocalypse an all), to see who is really right, cause christians are banking on the fact that Jesus was crucied for our sins and not because of our sins and we will all be forgiven because Jesus will be king, whereas the muslims say that he was not crucified and it is god our father that judges us. I'm being objective, unbiased and saying that judiaism, christianity, and islam all are unprovable empirically and faith based. Therefore, if we follow my solution and stick to my plan we can wait till the end of days to find out whose right, its just if we don't do something like this soon then, I'm afirad that the end of days will come sooner than we think, and there is still the major possibility that everyone(all religions) is wrong. I suck at spelling....huked on fanics yall

J Q Public

No and the same can be said about denying Palestine. They both exist and need to treat each other as fellow human beings. Denying peoples existence is childish.
Why are you looking for people to block? It don't make people disappear. Have a good day or night,whichever the case may be.

added. From what I have read here I can't see how there is a problem. Both sides say the other don't exist and if that is the case there is no one attacking the other side and no one defending from a non existent enemy. According to the posters here from both sides there can't be a conflict,non exsistent people can't cause problems for non existent people. It is no wonder a peace agreement can't be reached if the people here are an indication of the attitudes there.

Onichiwa Monaku

It never even existed anyways..it still remains palestine as it is.

Qazy Wabit

Ms Mich .....typical fantasy of a zionist & their cohorts . thinking if you can silence/block legitimate argument , then you have " taken over " .
Do go ahead & block me . If i have an ounce of the resilience of the Palestinians , nothing you do can stop me telling the truth .
ISRAEL DOES NOT EXIST . It has NO borders . It is a myth , long live Palestine. Justice will prevail .

STOP THE BLOODSHED & SLAUGHTER OF CHILDREN

then maybe we can recognize each other,

Rabbi for you

Of course not. Saying that is like hiding your head in the sand.
Israel EXISTS and the daily atrocities against Palestinian women and children (Philistine) are the obvious evidence of that.

Edit:
PAZIT, prove to me that you are really PAZIT and will prove to you that I am a real Rabbi.

And yes I got my ×¡×ž×™×›×” from the internet. Want to have one? They give them for free.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: