How large should the Jewish Territories be?

Show all answers

Maya

They have largely destroyed Palestine but fortunately the Palestinians have survived. Nevertheless for their multitudinous crimes against humanity they must be relocated,as well as for the future security of the Palestinian State. Texas sounds fine to me. George Bush is a fanatical zionist. So are most Texans. They should fit right in.

naserq22

Kevin S.
why do you have always to twist facts?
for the second Aliyah 1904 - 1914 Jews came from Russia and they "formed a self defense organizations"
defense !!!! against whom if there is no pple !!!!!
http://palestinecause.com/2008/10/jewish-immigration-to-palestine/#more-204
your claims of unpopulated land is a myth more than reality
it is as that writer who said for 30 miles each direction you see no life
I did calculated for you there as I am doing it to you again here
30 miles each direction that means 60 X 60 miles equals
100X 100 kilometers = 10 000 square kilometers almost the total of Palestine
and as I brought to you before in one small area I named for you cities not far from each another as 30 miles
30 miles =48 kilometers
Jerusalem -Ramallah (city north Jerusalem ) 18km
Jerusalem -Bethlehem 12 kms
Jerusalem -Lydda (Lod) 35 kms
Jerusalem -Yafa 50kms where lydda and Ramla is in between Jerusalem and Yafa
there are so many travelers who came and visit the holly land non of them reported it was "dry clean"
statistics shows
"Israeli refrencies"
by 1922
muslim Palestinians 589 000 = 78%
christian Palestinians 10%
Jews 12%
this figure is after the first and the second immigration for jews to palestine
http://www.mideastweb.org/palpop.htm

/\/

i think 0% sounds fine

Anonymous

how large? how about none? they dont deserve to be living on our land! we have fought to protect this land for centuries...and we will continue to do so. there are so many of us Palestinians, it is going to be impossible to dump us all someplace else. we are staying in Palestine..and them Jews can go and live in their original European countries

and, no....22.5% is still some Palestinians' homes. why deprive someone of their natural born rights to live, so that the jews can live on and enjoy our land. i think a son is more worthy of his mother, than a cousin would be.

we want our mother country....Palestine

Gerard de Rideforâ€

Go and watch Fox news it seems the brainwashing has worn of, if you carry on saying things like that you may start other people thinking.

younis q

if you just remember the palestinians refugees and their rights to returne bach , you will have better idea

Lebanese Angel

How about they all screw off !
because it's not their land and they're not wanted.

Put them all on one Island and strand them there.

Troy B

How about the pre-1967 borders.

Bosco

22.5% of texas.

Aldonbonn

Mr. Smartypantsâ„¢

True middle east born Jews should be able to live anywhere in Israel. The Jews of European origin and "settlers" should be regulated to certain areas where they won't feel paranoid, like back in Europe.

Bahira

None. Absolutely none. It is American fundamentalists who rave about them,so let them make the desert bloom in Texas. Texas is the Great Jewish Homeland as far as I am concerned.

Casablanca

It shouldn't be in the first place.

Forty 7

Israel rightfully deserves 0% of Palestine.

What the hell did the Palestinians do to deserve Israel being arbitrarily placed in their country??

Crystal (PSM)

How about 0.000000000000000000000000000000000000%?

Bosco: Are you insane? Why Texas?

tripper

No,it doesn't sound right. Jan Mayen Island sounds right.

writer

How large should the Muslim territories be? They already control 22 countries. About 80% of the land of Palestine in the 1920s became a Muslim land known as Transjordan (now Jordan).

Thus, the current day land of Israel makes up ~20% of the land of Palestine.

Jewish land is a teeny, itty, bitty piece of land. And Muslims took control of most of that after WWI.

Kai

How about 0%, as in I don't really see any reason it should exist at all. If it is going to exist then how about 10% of Palestine, as long as you can promise that all Jews from all over the world will stay there. But from a historical perspective the original Judea was roughly the current West Bank including Jerusalem, with the Palestinians have what is currently 'Israel', and I could accept that.

Kevin S

Europe tells the Jews to go back to palestine.......Jews enter Palestine.......start lives on unpopulated land or bought land.....attacks on Jews occur pre 1948 occur by arab groups from syria.....Hagannah evicts many arabs as punishment from certain cities through fear and harassment....Europe tells Jews to leave Palestine........

Romans believed we should never have our identity and our land. Many believe Jews are not an old ethnic group and have no land......Romans are successful thus far.

No! The Jews deserve all of Israel. Let all the palestinians go to Saudi Arabia or Egypt

Randal

110%. They'll sure as hell make more of it than anything you'll give the Palestinians. Even the Israeli Negev Desert is probably more developed than the lush farmland of the West Bank by now.

israel has already given away too much of its land. there's no such thing as palestine though.

shadyshinobi

How about 100%? As in, what we got.

If you could assure peace, well, then we could take negotions. But we're not giving you guys any favors until we know we're safe. You know, with all that "kill the infidel Jew" talk.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: