If Palestinians had their own INDEPENDENT state, would they still have to come to Israel? What do you think?

Show all answers

Actually the desire for a "Palestinian" state amongst Israelis has pretty much died since the pullout from Gaza since it did not end terrorist attacks, but only led to them increasing.

Arabs do not help "Palestinians" Israel provides free universal healthcare to "Palestinians" funded by the Israeli tax payer and provides them nearly 300 thousand work permits to work inside Israel. Plus gives asylum to over 20 thousand "Palestinian" women a year fleeing potential honor killing, incest and abusive husbands and fathers.

Arabs want the "palestinians" to stay in there situation because once there is a "Palestinian" state, they lose there excuse to hate Israel

HopelessZ00

I live in Canada and I DON'T HAVE TO go to America, so don't worry about it. But I do think Israelis will love over the border shopping, much cheaper in Arab lands for all or most goods. Israel is very expensive. Cheers!

AlessioIbrahim

Actually many people will tell you that JORDAN is their state and is where Palestinians sould go. But Palestinians dont want to relocate to what NOw is ANother country they want to stay in their own land!
They want All of Palestine

Stainless Steel

wonder what makes you jews think that you are welcome on that area?
Can't you see around you son?
Do you see any happy, smiling faces anywhere near you?
Do you feel even ...wanted?
Do you think that you are all ...cute? or even ..all sexy?
Or maybe you think that we are all ...jealous of you dude?
Wake up already! You're just day dreamin and that's not a good thing if you ask me.

The Palestinians,... no strike that out, ...WE ..prefer a peaceful nation in the Middle East and $16 Billion inside our pockets kid.
Does that answer your question?
Hope so.
Steel

[ImpaKt]Jr.

What we think?!

We think, you stole Palestinian's land. Period.

And when poor Palestinians get their lands/lives back,
there're many and i mean MANY who don't want to associate with you zions in any shape and form.

Sooner you people wake up, stop lying and being a total hypocrites(lol...also quit deleting your lying Que.'s/Answ's, when get caught!) better and much safer this world is going to be.

Note; glad some of these usual cut & past crowed with their usual 4 pages of crap as their responses! and BS links have finally awaken & realize the ridiculousness of it, also that no one is being impressed by that !

Noor

theres no such thing as "Israel"
if you don't want to see us, why don't you go back to your homeland.
it was Palestine, it's now Palestine and it will still be Palestine in the future.
we will gain it back, Zionists are just passing by.
it's in their holy Book and it's in mine.

gribela

Palestine was there first.

The jews started off as a nomadic people and in their travels saw the land of the Philistines (>Phalastinia>Palestinians) and decided it was good and they should steal it. That comes from their own historical record that they flaunt so boldly.

Long after the Romans kicked them out they eventually started to come back, but if it wasn't for their rich and powerful American brothers they wouldn't be able to sustain their foothold.

The Holy Land was NEVER an empty land. Every jewish incursion displaced the indigenous population, throughout history.

..LONG LIVE PALESTINE.. (Mina)

WAKE UP!!!!!!

How can you even expect them to just get their own land after everything of theirs has been stolen!

They are in their OWN land, if anyone needs their OWN land, its the Israelis.

Would it be fair for the Palestinians to go invade a country, force them to undergo "ethnic cleansing" and dispossession, and then STEAL their land with advanced weaponary while the real land settlers have nothing to defend themselves with???

Of course that wont be fair! So why is it OK for Israel to do that?

You want Palestinians to have their own independant state, THEN GIVE BACK THEIR LAND!

((Sorry for sounding a bit harsh, but thats just the way it is... Peace.))

dandyl

Israel wants to Palestinians to have there own state, so there could be peace, if there is peace then the Palestinians will be able to come into Israel freely.
I honestly do not know why there Arab brothers dont help them much.

Claymore Thomas III

No you maybe believe in whatever you want to believe son but I believe they don't feel comfortable near any jews.
I don't myself, just like Steel here.
Have you ever thought of this? I mean really thought of this?
Maybe this is the right time for you to start doing so kid.
Thomas

Bob Joke

Some of them would. Because many of them work in Israel. I don"t know why rich arab countries will not help them? Isn"t it funny that Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and those other countries like Iran blame Israel but then they do nothing to help the palestinians they claim to care about? What has Mahmoud Ahmadinejad done to help the palestinians?

"We think, you stole Palestinian's"

Yet Iran, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Qatar and Yemen are rich with oil money but can"t help the palestinians? Give me a break. Ahmadinejad don"t care about the palestinians. Palestinians are pawns of those rich arab countries. Saudi Arabia probaly one of the richest countries in the world and no help comes there to the palestinians? Why?

IPWNURLIFE

Yeah you fail. Israel used to be Palestinian land. The US simply usurped it and just gave it to you guys for religious reasons so Christians would be allowed in the holy land. I say we kick BOTH Palestinians and Israeli's out of Israel and turn the whole place into a Disney Land. Tell me that wouldn't be the best option. I dare you.

Why don't the Israelis give back the land they took and stop mowing it down with bulldozers and bombing it and stay in Israel? It was their land in the first place. Besides, what are the people of Israel going to do with the desert they have turned Palestine into? Quit all this stupid fighting. In the very end, everyone is going to be dead, so why not live life without anger and war?

gjiigi

yes and no

Kevin S

You do know that most of Israel is the Negev desert right? And do you also know that very little number of people live there, even now. Even the Bedouin Arabs never really lived there. Most Arabs lived near Syria or east of the Jordan river. Even till this day, in Israel, most Arabs live near Jordan river and near Syria. This is not a coincidence. For example, Tel Aviv had almost no Arabs and it was the first Jewish City. These aren't coincidences. One more thing.......if Palestinian Arabs created a sovereign state before 1948 (which they tried, just not hard enough), there would be no Israel today. A couple more ideas........there is no coincidence that people in Lebanon (in the south) have the same dialect as those that live in the west bank and those whom live in Jordan have the same dialect as well. It is sort of like a syrian dialect but with a lot of sh (which is common in Hebrew) instead of ssss. Another idea.......there were actually many Jews living in Palestine for the last 500 years or more. I have seen some of them and it's funny because Russian Jews look more middle eastern then them. My question is............did they speak Arabic?

jopalucas

First off, the land didnt come from America. It was set aside to relocate Jews after WW2 by the British.

The Palestinians left their land because they were told by Syria, Egypt, Jordan and Iraq that the land would be returned to them once the kicked the Jews out. Well, the Jews won the war, so the Palestinians bet on the losing side.

Jesus Touched Me

Palestine is their land. You stole it from them.

harajuku lover

palestinians belong in jordan. at least the bad ones do. there is nothing wrong with the good ones wanting to stay because israel treats them fine.

Get real. If the Pals hadn't spent all these years robbing killing and had even tried to set up peaceful relations they would have had a state and all the help they could stand from Israel.
Whether you give them statehood or not Israel needs to keep her borders firm against them or they would flood the country with suicidal maniacs.
The Pal society is not worthy of self government even if they were capable which they have shown they aren't. As long as the very top issue on the people's mind is the genocidal extinction of the Jew they will never be a state the world wants. Even the Arabs. Ask Jordan why they don't help out. Could it be the Pals wanted to kill their king and take over that land too.
These may be sweet people I don't know but the people they choose to lead shows their belligerence.

Bumbees

Didn't Israel give up a huge chunk of land a couple years ago? And didn't the Palestinians tear down every building that was there?

I too, wish the Palestinians would be given their own Independent State, this way, if a mortar attack should happen where they try to bomb a school - then war would be justified and the Israeli's could end it once & for all...

For the record - Arafat was given over $300,000,000.00 in monetary aid from neighboring Arab countries - however that money was going straight to a Swiss bank account that his wife & daughter in France are now enjoying... instead of to the people he claimed were starving

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: