If the Zionists are as bad as the Nazis, as many on Y!A claim, how can there any "Palestinians" alive?

Show all answers

Mimi-×ž×™×ž×™- Ù…ÙŠÙ…ÙŠ

The only difference between the Nazis and the zionists is that the Nazis killed 6 million Jews at once while the zionists have been killing the Palestinians for 60 years slowly slowly trying to get rid of them ten by ten so that the world doesn't notice.

Look how many children the IDF have killed in less than a year:
Somaya Samir Ata Oukal, 13, of Jabalya, Gaza, died of wounds sustained July 26 from IDF shelling which also killed her mother and two sisters (8/1/06)

Anis Salem Jadua abu-Awad, 11, of Rafah, Gaza, killed in an IDF airstrike (8/3/06)

Shahed Saleh Omar al-Sheikh Eid, 3 days, of Rafah, Gaza, killed by IDF shelling (8/4/06)

Ammar Raja al-Natour, 17, of Rafah, Gaza, killed, with his sister, by an IDF missile fired from a drone while fleeing shelling (8/5/06)

Kifah Raja al-Natour, 15, of Rafah, Gaza, killed, with her brother, by an IDF missile fired from a drone while fleeing shelling (8/5/06)

Ibrahim Suleiman al-Rumailat, 13, of Rafah, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile fired from a drone to his back and shoulder (8/5/06)

Raja Salam abu-Shaban, 3, of Gaza City, killed by an IDF missile (8/9/06)

Ahmad Hussein Muhammad al-Mishal, 16, of Shati refugee camp, Gaza, killed by IDF helicopter fire while working in an orchard (8/9/06)

Ahmad Yousef Abed Ashour, 13, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while in a crowd that gathered near the site of an abandoned Palestinian homemade rocket launcher (8/14/06)

Mustafa Hassan Ahmad Monsur, 17, of Rafah, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire during clashes at the Gaza perimeter fence (8/23/06)

Muntasser Suleiman Muhammad Akka, 15, of Askar refugee camp, killed by IDF gunfire to his back while throwing stones at IDF bulldozers destroying a building in Nablus (8/26/06)

Muhammad Abdullah Suleiman al-Ziq, 14, of Gaza City, killed by an IDF missile fired from a drone (8/29/06)

Nidal Abdul Aziz al-Dahdouh, 14, of Gaza City, killed by IDF sniper fire (8/30/06)

Hussam Ahmad Muhammad al-Sarsawi, 12, of Gaza City, died of wounds sustained Aug. 27 from IDF tank fire (8/30/06)

Ismael Majed Hamdan abu-Ruk, 15, of Khuzah, near Khan Younis, Gaza, killed by IDF sniper fire to his chest while on his roof during an incursion 9/6/06)

Jihad Suleiman Selmi abu-Snaima, 14, of Rafah, Gaza, killed by IDF shelling while at home near the Gaza airport (9/10/06)

Muhammad Omar Awad Shoriya, 13, of Rakhma, near Bethlehem, killed by IDF gunfire to his back while throwing stones at soldiers demolishing a Bethlehem home (9/12/06)

Hanan Muhammad Ismael abu-Odeh, 16, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, died of wounds sustained Sept. 2 from IDF gunfire while trying to help her father and older brother, who were also killed, in front of their home during an incursion (9/14/06)

Ala Saqer Dahrouj abu-Dahrouj, 15, of Jabalya, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while herding sheep (9/21/06)

Zidan Rafiq Muhammad abu-Rashid, 16, of Jabalya, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while herding sheep (9/21/06)

Muhammad Selmi Muhammad Masalha, 17, of Jabalya, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while herding sheep (9/21/06)

Damaliz Ahmad Muhammad Hamad, 14, of Rafah refugee camp, Gaza, killed in an IDF airstrike on a neighborâ€™s house (9/27/06)

Anwar Abdul-Ghani Muhammad Hamdan, 16, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, killed, with his brother, by an IDF missile while riding their bicycles past an abandoned Palestinian rocket launching site (9/29/06)

Hamam Abdul-Ghani Muhammad Hamdan, 13, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, killed, with his brother, by an IDF missile while riding their bicycles past an abandoned Palestinian rocket launching site (9/29/06)

Naji Khaled Ismael al-Bardawil, 15, of Khan Younis, Gaza, killed in an IDF missile strike on a neighboring building (10/3/06)

Mahmoud Jamal Ahmad abu-Nasr, 14, of Beit Lahya, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while salvaging an abandoned homemade rocket launcher (10/9/06)

Iman Usama Fadel al-Harazin, 2, of Gaza City, killed in an IDF airstrike while walking with her father (10/12/06)

Suhaib Adel Zerei Mahmoud Qudaih, 13, of Abasan al-Kabira, near Khan Younis, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while in his home (10/12/06)

Ibrahim Fuad Abdul-Latif al-Shanbari, 17, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire while involved in an inter-family dispute during an incursion (10/23/06)

Ahmad Kamal Muhammad al-Barim, 17, of Bani Suhaila, near Khan Younis, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire (10/26/06)

Mustafa Mustafa Jaber Jaber, 16, of Fara refugee camp, killed by IDF gunfire during an incursion (10/27/06)

Muhammad Samir Husseini Mahmoud, 17, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while administering first aid to a victim at the scene of a targeted assassination (11/2/06)

Bara Riyad Muhammad Fayyad, 4, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, died of wounds sustained Nov. 1 from IDF shelling of his home (11/2/06)

Ahmad Ismael Sahweel, 15, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to his chest during a demonstration (11/3/06)

Hamza Muhammad Ayub Karsua, 17, of Beit Lahya, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to his chest during a demonstration (11/3/06)

Hamdi Ramadan Muhammad Abdul-Dayem, 16, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to his chest near his home during a demonstration (11/3/06)

Raed Ali al-Majid Yasin, 15, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, killed in an IDF airstrike while at the scene of a targeted assassination (11/3/06)

Ibrahim Muhammad Ibrahim Sanakra, 15, of Balata refugee camp, killed by IDF gunfire while trying to help his wounded brother, the target of an assassination attempt (11/3/06)

Abdul-Karim Khalil Ayyad Subih, 16, of al-Saf, near Bethlehem, killed by IDF gunfire to his head while throwing stones at bulldozers destroying a neighborhood home (11/3/06)

Ibrahim Jamal Hasan al-Bassiuni, 17, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, died of wounds sustained Nov. 3 from IDF helicopter fire during an incursion (11/4/06)

Muhammad Ibrahim Abed Balousha, 15, of Gaza City, killed by IDF gunfire to his head (11/4/06)

Walah Talal Abdul-Karim Nasr, 13, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to her head while trying to escape bulldozers destroying her home (11/4/06)

Ramzi Mowafaq al-Shrafi, 16, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while on his way to school (11/6/06)

Fatima Masoud Abdullah al-Athamna, 16, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Mahdi Said Abdullah al-Athamna, 13, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Muhammad Said Abdullah al-Athamna, 14, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Saad Majdi Said al-Athamna, 8, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Mahmoud Amjad al-Athamna, 12, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Maram Ramez Masoud al-Athamna, 2, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Maisa Ramez Masoud al-Athamna, 6 months, of Beit Hanoun, Gaza, killed, with 16 family members, by IDF shelling while asleep at home (11/8/06)

Nimer Muhammad Ali abu-Nadia, 17, of Jabalya, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to his chest (11/8/06)

Musa Ahmad Musleh Zuhod, 14, of Beit Lahya, Gaza, killed by an IDF missile while standing near a homemade Palestinian rocket launcher (11/12/06)

Mahmoud Hussein Mustafa abu-Hamada, 17, of Jabalya, Gaza, died of wounds sustained Nov. 6 from an IDF missile strike at the Jabalya Youth Club (11/12/06)

Thaer Hasan Abed al-Masri, 17, of Bedouin village, near Beit Layha, Gaza, killed by IDF gunfire to his neck and chest while farming near his home during an incursion (11/18/06)

Rakan Abed Kayed Nuseirat, 16, of al-Auja, near Jericho, killed by the IDF at the al-Dyouk checkpoint while holding a toy gun on his way home (11/20/06)

Adham Khaled al-Sahabani, 17, of Gaza City, killed by IDF gunfire to his head while riding in a car (11/22/06)

Abdul-Aziz Salman Muhammad Salman, 10, of Beit Lahya, Gaza, killed by IDF tank fire to his abdomen while playing by al-Zawia mosque (11/24/06)

Shadi Isam Nayef Bani-Shams, 17, of Beita, near Nablus, killed by IDF gunfire to his abdomen while throwing stones during an incursion (11/30/06)

Ayman Abdul Qader abu-Mahdi, 10, of Jabalya refugee camp, Gaza, died of head wounds sustained Nov. 25 from IDF gunfire while playing near his home (12/2/06)

Jamil Abdul-Karim Jamil Jabji, 5, of Askar refugee camp, killed by IDF gunfire from a jeep to his head while throwing stones (12/3/06)

Ala Ahmad Muhammad Makawi, 17, of Gaza City, killed by IDF gunfire while trying to cross the Gaza perimeter fence (12/13/06)

Doa Nasr Saleh Abdul-Qader, 13, of Faroun, near Tulkarm, killed by IDF gunfire from a jeep to her chest and hand while going to visit her friendâ€™s grandmother near the annexation wall (12/19/06)

Ala Fawaz Muhammad Hamran, 16, of Araba, near Jenin, killed by undercover IDF gunfire during an incursion into Ramallah (1/4/07)

Abir Bassam Abed-Rabo al-Aramin, 10, of Anata, near Jerusalem, died of head wounds sustained on Jan. 17 from an IDF percussion grenade while in her schoolyard during a demonstration against the annexation wall (1/18/07)

Mahmoud Hussam abu-Salha, 15, of Nablus, killed by IDF gunfire to his head while throwing stones during an incursion (1/18/07)

Mahran Zakaria Salman abu-Nsir, 16, of Deir al-Balah, killed by IDF gunfire while trying to cross the Gaza perimeter fence for work in Israel (1/24/07)

Fadel Mutlaq Daji Balawna, 17, of Tulkarm, killed by undercover IDF gunfire to his back while attempting to escape arrest (1/27/07)

Taha Muhammad Subhi al-Qualjawi, 16, of Kafr Aqab, near Jerusalem, killed by IDF gunfire to his thigh while trying to cross Israel's annexation wall.

***

crookedstepvmx

All a zionist is, is a person who believes that Israel has a right to exist. The Zionist focus is on supporting the continued existence of Israel as the official Jewish State, the Nazi focus was on the "final solution" to the "jewish problem" by extermination.

I don't see how they're similar at all, much less that Zionists are "as bad as Nazis"

Please ignore these people for the crackpots that they are.

Israelis are killers

Hitler was a Jew and 60% of nazis were Jewish. They killed each others and now are killing the innocent pals.

MBC

Point well-taken. That is not to say that Israel is innocent here, but hyperbolic statements comparing Israelis to Nazis will get us nowhere. The fact is, if Israel wanted to wipe out the Palestinians currently residing within Israel and/or the OT, it could have done so long ago, and I'm not sure that anyone would have stopped them. We have seen a number of examples of true genocide going unchecked since the inception of the State of Israel- Cambodia, Laos, Rwanda, Darfur, to name a few. Israel could have gone down that road, and there may be some within Israel that would support it and carry it out. But let's call things as they are- unjust, cruel, collectively punishing, yes, but genocidal, no.

I would also take issue with your use of quotes around the word Palestinian. Why do that? Why deligitimize a people just because you don't like the fact that they exist? If you want to make the silly argument that Palestinians are really Syrians and never called themselves Palestinians, go ahead. But at this point it is just mean-spirited to use these quotes. They identify themselves as such, and so should everyone else.

Even if one accepted that logic, it could easily be said of Israelis as well. Before 1947, were there any Israelis? There were the ancient ISREALITES, but no Israelis. Shall I now start writing "Israelis" every time I mention the word? There were no Americans 300 years ago. Should everyone start writing "Americans"?

Bug Eye

95% of Palestinians are currently without a country.

If most Palestinians are good, and only a handful are bad, and only 5% are left, why cant the best army in the world catch them, without killing innocent civilians? Not should give you something to think about...

MikeInRI

The people who say that Zionists are as bad as Nazis have serious mental issues. Do not worry about these people - just block them and hopefully Yahoo will eventually realize how detrimental such people are to their company. Either that or welcome MSN in when it takes over Yahoo because those who run the company cannot do a competent job with it.

Good Luck!!!

rosends

because "Palestinian" simply means "someone from the region on the map which used to be called Palestine. This refers to Arabs, Christians and Jews who lived in the region pre-1948. Why would anyone want to kill people just because they lived there before there was any country there.

Blue Xull

Well, just as there are many "Jews" alive. they are dying and suffering.
___
'''''''''''
Countering Some people's null evidence. (aka Paperback's, Mimi so busy is right, lol)

I have a 48 page list of only CHILDREN who have died in Israel bombings,

Jeez! 47 pages? OMG that beats every statistic, I'm astonished by the validity of your logic!

there are people being treated in the hospital huh? heres a leaked example, a mother who was prevented from going to the hospital after an Israeli bomb exploded in her house and Israelis didn't let them call the ambulance! btw, ISRAEL ADMITS MISTAKE, imagine! A Jew (the superior race) admits mistake (she dies):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tW1-_JmXQt0

Iran, PLO and Hamas are the only ones against Israel?
Interestingly the Jewish lobby sends threatening messages to people who don't support the Israel's cause, even US politicians. A US CONGRESSMAN SAYS SO (let alone supporting the Palestinian cause):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHciQh2i6gw

how can they do that?:

This is the person who arrested people for speaking ill of Israel, would you believe eventually those detentions led to his fall from ULTIMATE POWER over an entire country, he is not biased, even he says the Israeli lobby controls the US:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQgZ3oLp_WY
____
''''''''''''''

Duke of Tudor

Unlike Hitler and his Nazi who wished to exterminate ALL Jewish people, Israel has no intention whatsoever to eliminate the Palestinian Arabs. Had the Arab governments accepted the 1947 Partition Plan, the Palestinian Arabs would have their own state since 60 years ago.

Unless you have a better name for the Palestinian Arabs, kindly omit the " mark the next time you want to type Palestinians.

Dustinthewind

To mimi so bussy. It is sad when innocent people get harmed. Im not defending every incident of shootings because I know not everyone is innocent. But I do ask my self this. Why do the men of war hide behind the innocent for their operations (build bunkers next to their houses) if they don't want their innocent people harmed? This seems to show a lack of concern for the well being of their children? Of course there are the incidents when a strike on an enemy goes terribly wrong beyond intention, those are truly sad. I also ask my self another question. What about the men who launch missiles into Israel at no particular targets except innocent civilians? What kind of people are these? What goes through their minds? Unfortunately for to long there has been strife, contention, and bickering. What will it take for this "human mind strong hold" to be broken?

umm I've never made that comparison that you mentioned but just a small tip for your next question, Nazis didn't kill all Jews either. Oh and btw putting a '' '' like that just makes you look stupid (no offense--)

Hey paperback, welcome back, where did I say that? And you'd know about lying I'm sure.... (I'm gonna be nice and -- .)

Lost my everything..

There is..but in suffering don't you know?I pity them..

Bosco

Simple. You are utterly dependent on the Americans and they will not let you. Should you ever obtain independence from the U.S. you would kill every Palestinian you could get your hands on.

paperback writer

Like MIMI, I too have a list. Currently it stands at 47 pages long and it's the number of Israeli civilians that have died recently at the hands of Palestinian terrorism.

The Israeli town Sderot is the most bombed area in the world at present. Right now two young brothers are fighting for their lives in hospital; one has already lost a leg. They are two more victims of the relentless rocket attacks from Gaza.

Next time someone hysterically shrieks 'genocide' in regard to the Palestinians, see what happens when you ask them for any PROOF. They'll never be able to provide any. Because, of course, there is no 'genocide' happening.

The number of Palestinians is steadily increasing. That doesn't happen if 'genocide' is going on.

Interestingly, the ONLY people to speak of wishing to commit genocide are Hamas, the PLO, and Iran. The official charters of both Hamas and the PLO both demand that Israel is totally wiped out and that every Jew living there is slaughtered. Iran continues to issue threats over 'removing' Israel from the world map.

The Palestinians have indeed suffered - but not because of Israel. They were deceived by the leaders of the Arab world who told them to flee their homes ahead of the five Arab armies who then attacked Israel in 1948. They told the Palestinian Arabs they would get their homes back - and then left them to rot in camps in Egypt and Jordan.

TZIZIT - *sigh* Get a grip. Hitler was NOT Jewish, the Nazis were NOT Jewish. Do yourself a big favour and pick up a history book.

B is lying. She DID make that analogy, some weeks back when she referred to Jews and Israelis as 'Zionazis'.

Pee-Pee Gorilla

It's good you didn't finish all of them. How merciful of you!

Pedantic Exactitude

Ah, there is a difference between being as morally bad as the Nazis and having the same amount of power and scope as the Nazis. Thus, Zionists have not been able to exterminate the Palestinians as there are Arab governments able to provide sanctuary.

I disagree with the moral equivalence argument, though we must not ever think either side in this messy conflict is as pure as the driven snow.

spider man

Well the process is ongoingâ€¦ultimately Israel is planning into killing all non-Jews everywhereâ€¦
And the elimination of the Palestinian children is at the top of the Israeli agendaâ€¦

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: