Is "israel" the Nazi Germany of the modern Mideast?

Show all answers

Maya

Yes. There are many points of comparison. The incessant invasions of neighboring states. The immense military. The emphasis on air power. The unity of race,soil and government. The cult mentality,including the willingness to self-destruct if they are headed for extinction. The love of death. The excessive use of symbols with deep iconographic resonance. yes,they're back. And this time they are jewish - irony of ironies - and this time the plague besets the Mideast,not Europe.

Bravo Sierra

Yes, same school.
Those wondering why Zionists today are so organized and experienced in their public relations efforts discover that these battles have been fought before. Moreover, the section on Nazi and Zionist understandings of "nationality" versus citizenship reveals how German and Israeli practices are based on the same concept.

Bosco

It certainly is. And it's American counterparts - these so-called jewish organizations - are simply nazi propaganda organs.

Nora

Yes, it is. Israel wants to have a jewish state like the Nazis wanted Germany to be a pure aryan race. Like the Nazis, Israel kills and jails Palestinian children. The list of Israel's crime is huge and has been going on for 60 years, Israel also has unleashed many holocausts on the Palestinians, the most recent one took place in Gaza. Even a U.N. expert compared Israel to Nazi Germany.
http://www.jerusalemites.org/News%20In%20English/english/march2005/8.htm

Sophia B

Israel is more the Nazi Poland and Austria and other countries that the Germans invaded. The Nazis didn't go into Germany and kill off the Germans. Both ways are wrong, of course, but that's the only difference, so its worth noting.

naserq22

they sure are different
the german nazy worked to bring all the worlds hatred for things that they were doing
but in this case we see the world is wide shutting his eyes
the resistance against german invasion was helped and aided by the world we saw charl de gaul was in britain leading the french resistance while in here the world had accepted the term terror to descripe the resistant
the concentration camps in germany were held"...." for a group of pple but in this case the concentration camps is held for all palestinians
the colloqual punishment for palestinians is a fact but the world is not pointing it out ,even the world including neighbouring countries are helping in it
the period of time till the world moves against germany was some couple of years while in this case 60 years already passed and the world still looks at the 194 or 242 338 as history nothing more mean while iraq must fulfill all the UN resolutions till the last of it
world had helped in real interfering to end nazism while the world promised arabs to solve the issue just if arabs help in war against saddam 1991 ,although help was offered but nothing was done later

Arabianstallion00

Yes, only this time the massacres they commit are for real and are not exaggerated.

great gonzo the cybernetic ape

There are many reasons to say yes
And for thinking that i didn't join the army.
Didn't want to be a part of a Nazi army
But it's a little different

First we are not as smart
And we don't really want to kill all of the Palestinians.
We just want them to live... lol

We are evil
But the Nazis were way more sinister

Stainless Steel

I don't know about the "NAZI" term but the jews are doing some pretty nasty shooting over there.
I mean, killing children and all, kind of a genocide if you ask me.
I would hesitate to use the NAZI term because I respect the holocost victims, that's all.

tamarindwalk

Hardly...

While some of its government people are applying first-hand knowledge gained from their subjugation by the Nazis, the majority of Israelis are not at all like that - or so I believe.

I may be angry at the Israeli government, but at the people of Israel, I am not. And I cannot possibly imagine equating them to Nazis.

David N

You idiot, made me open a new acct, you and your moronic band of followers.
Are you really happy with these answers, how old are you, or should I ask is your IQ a single digit or a low two digit.
I'm done now. pissssonyou.

ASK Maya ABOUT THE REVELATION SHE HAD !!!

dandyl

how can anyone compare the natzis to israel, you should be more educated then that and not post such ignorant questions
This is perhaps the most odious claim made by Israel's detractors. The Nazis' objective was the systematic extermination of every Jew in Europe. Israel is seeking peace with its Palestinian neighbors. More than one million Arabs live as free and equal citizens in Israel. Of the Palestinians in the territories, 98 percent live under the civil administration of the Palestinian Authority. While Israel sometimes employs harsh measures against Palestinians in the territories to protect Israeli citizens â€“ Jews and non-Jews â€“ from the incessant campaign of terror waged by the PA and Islamic radicals, there is no plan to persecute, exterminate, or expel the Palestinian people.

In response to one such comparison, by a poet who referred to the "Zionist SS," The New Republic's literary editor Leon Wieseltier observed:

The view that Zionism is Nazism â€” there is no other way to understand the phrase â€œZionist SSâ€ â€” is not different in kind from the view that the moon is cheese. It is not only spectacularly wrong, it is also spectacularly unintelligent. I will not offend myself (that would be self-hate speech!) by patiently explaining why the State of Israel is unlike the Third Reich, except to say that nothing that has befallen the Palestinians under Israel's control may responsibly be compared to what befell the Jews under Germany's control, and that a considerable number of the people who have toiled diligently to find peace and justice for the Palestinians, and a solution to this savage conflict, have been Israeli, some of them even Israeli prime ministers. There is no support for the Palestinian cause this side of decency that can justify the locution â€œZionist SS.â€10

The absurdity of the charge is also clear from the demography of the disputed territories. While detractors make outrageous claims about Israel committing genocide or ethnic cleansing, the Palestinian population has continued to explode. In Gaza, for example, the population increased from 731,000 in July 1994 to 1,324,991 in 2004, an increase of 81 percent. The growth rate was 3.8 percent, one of the highest in the world. According to the UN, the total Palestinian population in all the disputed territories (they include Gaza, the West Bank, and East Jerusalem) was 1,006,000 in 1950, and rose to 1,094,000 in 1970, and exploded to 2,152,000 in 1990. Anthony Cordesman notes the increase â€œwas the result of improvements in income and health servicesâ€ made by Israel. The Palestinian population has continued to grow exponentially and was estimated in 2004 at more than 3.6 million

NYC Chutzpah

Think you got it backwards. You mistake defensive moves as offensive. If rockets stopped raining down on Israel there would be no checkpoints, no targeted killings etc.Israel has not threatened to wipe arabs off the map. Israel has not shouted Death to the arabs.The nazis tried to kill all Jews. The arabs are still trying to. Ain't gonna happen.
Am Yisrael Chai

Cher JPA

It's mean to call Jews/Israel Nazis, and it reflects badly on those who do it. No matter what you're political point of view.

There aren't any real comparisions. The ME is at war. In Germany, Jews were some 1/2 percent, integrated, & doing nothing in particular. A little reading on Nazi Germany and it makes Israel look like saints.

It's like calling all Arabs or Muslims terrorists.

Snow

Isreal has the right to defend itself.
US is working on a road map.
Democracy and freedom.
Mahmood Abbas & Rice will bring that freedom to Palestinians
Sweet children
http://news.yahoo.com/nphotos/Mideast-Conflict-Gaza-Strip/ss/events/wl/080601mideast/s:/ap/20080429/ap_on_re_mi_ea/israel_palestinians/im:/080428/481/7dcf8f26aa6c43b88b51eec1773dbc0a/;_ylt=Ai2KD1Qva_vfIOtu6J1DuEMUewgF#photoViewer=/080428/photos_wl_afp/df8c81ecd009656657476c3d54ea57b6
http://news.yahoo.com/nphotos/Mideast-Conflict-Gaza-Strip/ss/events/wl/080601mideast/s:/ap/20080429/ap_on_re_mi_ea/israel_palestinians/im:/080428/481/7dcf8f26aa6c43b88b51eec1773dbc0a/;_ylt=Ai2KD1Qva_vfIOtu6J1DuEMUewgF
http://media.npr.org/news/images/2005/nov/14/reuters/rice200.jpg

â™¥ PEACE NOW â™¥

all the answers you received and will continue receive are from hamas supporter and anti-israelis. sure they'll say yes.
for me--- i don't know man!!
i don't care!

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: