What about a 3 state solution?

Show all answers

PloniAlmoni

The Jews are not trying to create a country "just for them" 20% of Israeli citizens are Arab and there are more Russian Christians, Armenian Christians, Iranian Bahai, Druze, Ethiopian Christians and so on... Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are the ones who do not want to allow Jews to live with them. This is why Jewish neighborhoods in the West Bank (even areas that have been fully bought completely legally) must have military to guard them.

It is true that Jordan was originally part of the British mandate of Palestine therefor they gave the majority of the country to the Arabs and left a small portion to the Jews, even still the Arabs wanted more and the UN gave them an additional state however they did not accept the state because they do not want to live next to a Jewish state under any circumstances. They also do not want Jews to live as a minority in their country (as shown by the expulsion of 1 million Jews from Arab countries).

The 3 state solution would be great, the 2 state solution would be great, the 15 state solution would be great but the Arabs have to agree to Jews living in their ancestral land and this will not happen anytime soon.

Annt Hu DeShalit

There are two states at present.

One is Israel, which is inhabited 80 percnet by Jews and 20 percent by Arabs.

Another land is 80 percent Palestinians and is relatively liberated. It is known as the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.

Jordan is indeed Palestine. This Arab state already was carved out of 76% of mandatory Palestine. It was first called Transjordan and now is known as Jordan. It was given as a gift to Emir Abdullah by the British.

So the solution already exists.

.

Alan M

But where will Hamas the child killing terror group go ? They accept only the deaths of all Jewish children. Land means nothing to them.

mir miron

1.Listen, there is a Jewish Israeli country called Israel, the country has a large Arab population. (so that's 2 and 3 for you)

2. As for 1
The Arab world (Arabic: العالم العربي; Transliteration: al-`alam al-`arabi) is a term to define all of the Arabic-speaking countries stretching from the Atlantic Ocean in the west to the Arabian Sea in the east, and from the Mediterranean Sea in the north to the Horn of Africa and the Indian Ocean in the southeast. It consists of about 21 countries and territories with a combined population of some 325 million people spanning two continents.

1: Kuwait (Kuwait)

2: Iraq (Baghdad)

3: Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (Riyadh)

4: Bahrain (Manama)

5: Qatar (Doha)

6: United Arab Emirates (Abu Dhabi)

7: Oman (Mascut)

8: Yemen (Sana'a)

9: Jordan (Amman)

)

11: Lebanon (Beirut)

12: Syria (Damascus)

13: Egypt (Cairo)

14: Sudan (Khartum)

15: DDjibouti (Djuboti)

16: Libya (Tripoli)

17: Tunisia (Tunis)

18: Algeria (Alger)

19: Morocco (Rabat)

20: Mauritania (Nowakshot)

21: Comoros (Moroni)

DO YOU REALLY THINK THERE SHOULD BE MORE ARAB COUNTRIES ?? I MARKED MORE WITH )

michelle

I for the Arabs and Jews to be educated on how to get along. LOL

Too have some peace in this world.

Chani M

great idea except neither of them will ever agree to this

^ PaLo ^

Your name answers the question ;)

Warren S

It now appears that there is a four state solution in the making. They are as follows:
Jordan (Palestinian population about 70% and the land is 80% of the British Mandate)
Israel, the Jewish State about 10% of the 1920 British Mandate.
West Bank which is currently claimed by Fatah and challenged by Hamas.
Gaza, the Hamas enclave and terror central in the area.

Israelichick

i don't think there is anything left to split

IGAL

IMPOSSIBLE.. sorry but it will never work out.
First of all Jews and the Muslims would fight over Jerusalem. Neither will ever give it up.
Second i know for a fact that most of the people fighting for over 60 years are fighting for their FULL land as in in the whole country and will never settle for less.

Kevin S

"1 for Arabs and Jews who realize that this mess started a long time ago and now they just want to be friends and get along."

There is no such thing.........

devora k

Great to dream It won't happen

Arieh

If 1.5 million Arabs can live in Israel, why can't some Jews live in Palestine?

Palestine

that is not too shabby of a plan, but explaining this to Israeli and Palestinian leader is impossible.

You won't stay on stage long with that comedy routine.

Six State Solution sounds more realistic :

1 for the Pals

1 for Hamas

1 for Nasr Allah

1 for the Russians

1 for the Ethiopians

and finally

1 for the Jews

Calvin79

Very unlikely to happen.

¨°º¤ø„¸ COOPS ¸„ø¤º°¨

there's no room in tiny israel for all that. maybe huge empty jordan will give out a piece for the arab community, they have enough room... and not the west bank, that's where i live (in a legal city, thank you very much).

Ferrari Enzo

The problem is not how many states there are, it's that israel doesn't give anyone a chance to live in peace

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: