What is the difference between nazi germany and israel?

Show all answers

B B

Nazi Germany is history. Israel is still practicing Nazi role

Will Smith

Nazi Germany is past.

PaperbackWriter JPA

What is the similarity?

Israel is an open and secular democracy. Arabs and Muslims sit in the Israeli parliament and help, make and break policy. There are Gay Pride marches in Jerusalem. Israelis are of all colours, ethnicities and faiths. All have the same rights to vote and worship. There is a free and vibrant press. Israel is the only nation in the region where Arab women get to VOTE.

Nazi Germany was not a democracy. Millions of Jews were murdered purely for their faith, despite being loyal citizens. Gays were murdered, JWs were murdered, the handicapped were murdered. One million Jewish children were butchered. Anyone who opposed Hitler who was not 'aryan' enough was killed.

So again I ask you: what is the similarity?

Claymore Thomas III

Are you ready buddy?
The Germans gave humanity:

radars and ASDIC (sonar)
vacuum tubes
Colossus (First supercomputer)
synthetic rubber (Yes !!! Nylon !!!)
alternative fuels as in hydrogen peroxide (Wow!!)
Penicillin
Aspirin
Atomic Energy
Submarines
Diesel Engines
Wankel engines
jet Aircrafts
Helicopters
Turbo engines
Laser beam
Tape recorders
Solar cells
Do you want me to go on?
These guys were some Godlike folks that their brains used to work twice as fast from the rest of us.

Israel?
The Palestinian holocaust.
Russian Immigrants
Tried to turn us against the Muslims (did not work)
A mess in the Middle East.

Thomas

Edit________________
Imagine your life without these German goodies, dude!
No way!

Zeno

The similarities; both are ferociously aggressive and modeled on the ethnocratic state. Both are cultures based on both false presumptions of "race" and on their own alleged racial superiority. Both demonstrate indifference to international law and a basic respect for human life and dignity. The differences: Germany required no sponsor,whereas Tel Aviv has gone from Russia to France and finally the U.S. It could not survive diplomatically or militarily without a major-state sponsor. It is able to garner positive publicity far more successfully than the Third Reich. It has a pseudo-theological justification in the God-land-grant. One more similarity is the Ancestral Land Claim.

Ma'akum

None to speak of; they are both brutal ethnocracies. The only difference is size.

Just another Greek Guy

There is nowhere recorded that the Germans had ever killed 500 children and 700 civilians in just three weeks.
Never!
Personally after seeing what it's been happening in Palestine, I am not sure that the Germans really did what the jews are accusing them of doing.
I think they made most of that in some Hollywood studios.
As far as I know the Germans fought a war and lost.
That's a very old story and it doesn't concern us anymore.
let's see what's been happening today people!

Honored Knight !!

the nazi dont act victims when they do what they do

the israelies are experts at acting victims

SJC

DEMOCRACY!!

Bosco

Only one. They don't control the continent; if they did they would exterminate the Arabs,I have no doubt of that.

Isis

i can hardly see any difference germany wanted a pure aryan race and Israel is about having a state for the jews and therefore they kill a non jews. israel hascommitted many masscres in the region they are nothing but trouble makers. The Nazis did not demolish homes but Israel does destroy the homes of Palestinians to steal their land. Israelis are also holding Palestinian children as young as 11 in israeli prison where they are brutally tortured. I can give a huge list of crimes comitted by israel over the last 60 years but unforunately i have to go now.

JayJay

that peres doesn't have a mustache ?

kismet

There are many differences between the two, but no similarities whatsoever.

Cher JPA

One has you to bad mouth Jews with lies, & the other doesn't.

I'm sure you would have joined in if you were alive then too.

To learn more:
http://www.nizkor.org
Shouldn't take long to see how offensive this question is.

Photo Finnish

I agree with Thomas!
it is exactly the same!
Israel is Palestine in truth, right?
I just love Palestine, it's so .. so.... hip!
Gaza is my next holiday destination when Obama finishes off working his magic, heheheh!

Arieh

If you don't see any difference then you are probably an uneducated teenager. That's the only excuse for your ignorant point of view.

Meh

Goodwins law. Google it.

You cant see a difference because you are ignorant and lack historical knowledge. Where Israel represent an overly aggressive war monger, the Nazi Party in Germany instigated an industrial system to exterminate 6 million people using as little violence or human interaction as possible.

If you cant see a difference, you are per definition ignorant and you contribute to the escalation of the conflict between Israel and Palestine. You should be ashamed of yourself. It is because of people like you, who draw conclusions about a certain type of people based on nothing but ignorant agression, that cause violence and conflict.

Heres a tip: from now on, when something seems obvious to you, you should realise its because you dont know anything about it.

The First Dragon

If you don't see any difference between Nazi Germany and Israel, you haven't read the history of either country.
Nazi Germany was a socialist dictatorship with racist ideals, and deliberately set out to kill those of its own citizens that they considered in any way undesirable.
Israel is basically capitalist Democracy set up as a homeland for Jews of any race whatsoever. It also includes many Arabs who are born citizens of Israel, and other religions too.
The PLO is the organization which has historically been run despotically, with the intention of getting rid of all Jews. Israel has no desire to get rid of Arabs; only to protect itself from attack. But Palestinians of the anti-Jewish variety have always kept defenseless civilians in the vicinity of their weapons sites. Israel has the unpleasant choice between killing Palestinian children who have been put in harm's way by Palestinian fighters; or allowing those Palestinian fighters to kill Israeli children, whom Israelis always keep far away from Israeli military sites.
Palestinians are the ones who have in their Charters that Jews are to be killed or driven out of the land. Palestinians are the ones that will target civilians rather than the military. I know there are a lot of decent Palestinians that aren't in favor of this; but they are unable or unwilling to stop it.

numnum

did you bother to take a look at hamas agenda? they specificly state that they want jews killed. and you compare israel to nazis. funny man you are.

Ella

Only size and control by ownership of much of the major-state media.

Annt Hu DeShalit

The lack of sensitivity expressed by this question boggles the imagination.

Comparisons between Israel and apartheid in South Africa are bad enough -- Israel does not have a scientific/theological theoretical apparatus justifying suppression of Arabs -- but this is one of the most pernicious falsehoods of modern times.

Israel is not trying to exterminate its Arab population -- they have the vote and are represented in the Knesset, and even have a deputy minister and an ambassador to a foreign country.

What Israel is trying to do, and maybe we feel embarrassed by it, is to defend itself against fanatics who fire rockets at its civilians.

.

Sabrina

Nazis aren't human beings in my opinion..they are like robots/monsters that just follow orders and torment others!!
Israel on the other hand value life and is only protecting their country from terrorists commonly known as Hamas and many other terrorist organizations that blow themselves up inorder to kill other innocent people, and they have no value for life whatsoever!! They're like brainwashed monsters!!!

Whoh, i just came up with a new question: What is the difference between Hamas and Nazi Germany?

Two different worlds. Same as today.

Teresa (SFECU) -†- pray4revival

The primary difference is this:

During WWII a blind world finally woke up to Nazi Germany and realized who the evil entity really was and who the victims were.

In the case of Israel, the again blind world is still seeing Israel as the evil entity and the real evil entity as the victims.

Don't you think it's time you opened your eyes to the truth?

Israel is NOT the evil entity here.

Tyreeisme!

how ignorant to use Nazi Germany against Israel and Jewish people!In the recent news Israel was defending its self against an unjustified attack by Hamas,.in Nazi Germany people were killed in horrific ways ripped apart and turned into soap.You can have a gripe against Israel, it is not a perfect society but it is a democracy .How dare you use our own Holocaust against us!!!!!!!Israel has returned land in Gaza and West bank to Palestinian control and also made peace with Jordan and Egypt .Israel gets rockets back as a thank you!(from Hamas)

hazaamohammed

the NAZI Germany killed innocent people and Israel kills the terrorists who intended to destroy and kill Jews. so long live for the state of Israel and death for the its enemy from the west to the East huge difference ha have nice day

Unknown

Israel is a liberal democracy, Nazi Germany was a totalitarian dictatorship.

moneymaxer

Of course you don't! You have never been to the Nazi Germany, or Israel!

Gosh... some jackasses try to make people out of themselves and that just makes me laugh...

Skidoo

I fail to see any similarities.

✡I LOVE THE ZIONIST ENTITY✡

Many.

But Hamas has a lot of similarities...

I find the current situation deeply sorrowful, harrowing. There is one aspect of it that I think needs clarification, a clarification that will help thinking about the situation as a whole, and that is the analogies between Hitler, the Nazis and Hamas.

So, as the author of Explaining Hitler, having spent some time studying the subject, I thought I would point out a few differences.

–The Hamas founding covenant explicitly calls for the extermination of all Jews. Hitler never made total extermination an official plank of the the Nazi party platform. (see Holocaust scholar Omer Bartov’s article in the February 2, 2004 issue of The New Republic. He points to the extermiationist 7th article of the founding Hamas covenanat which cites the Hadith (saying of the prophet). Here is a translation of the Hadith in a deeply disturbing summary of Hamas’ exterminationist anti-semitism by the Brown University scholar Andrew Bostom:

“The Prophet, Allah’s prayer and peace be upon him, says: “The hour of judgment shall not come until the Muslims fight the Jews and kill them, so that the Jews hide behind trees and stones, and each tree and stone will say: ‘Oh Muslim, oh servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him,’ except for the Gharqad tree, for it is the tree of the Jews.” (Sahih Muslim, Book 41, Number 6985)

In other words, Hamas is not committed merely to the political goal of expelling Jews from the land of Israel but to what they believe is a sacred religious goal of exterminating all Jews everywhere behind every tree in creation. (I’m not pinning any hopes on “the Gharqad tree”). I’d suggest those who deceive themselves into believing Hamas is just another Palestinian rights group, maybe a little on the extreme side, read the whole Bostom article. The exterminationist anti-semitism of Hamas is more excessive than Hitler’s.

So that’s one difference.

–Hitler made efforts to conceal the purpose of the death camps and distanced himself from them, avoided written as opposed to oral orders for the Final Solution. Not because he felt any shame about them, but because he felt knowledge of the death camps might be counter-productive to the Nazis political goals. Hamas makes no effort to conceal the fact that it wants to kill Jewish civilians, not just combatants, but women and children–all Jews (it’s in the charter, remember)—because Hamas feels this will make them more popular.
Those who point to the inefficiency of Hamas rocket attacks act as if they wouldn’t be happy to have more efficient or deadly rockets or that they regret the ones that fall on kindergartens and hospitals.

So Hamas’ open pride in its mass murder goal–that’s another difference between Hamas and Hitler.

–Hitler’s party came to power in part because of the claim Germany’s lands had been stolen from it and it would reclaim them. Hitler did not (inititally) call for the murder of all those who had lived on the land long before World War I. (he didn’t for instance, want to murder all the Czechs in the Sudetenland, just return it to its pre-war German identity). Hamas came to power with the claim that the Palestinian lands had been stolen from them and that it would murder all Jews living there however long they or their families had been there. So there’s another difference.

–Hamas calls for a system of law in which women are mutilated and murdered (sometimes beheaded) if they dare to transgress their inferior status under sharia law (and approves crucifixion as a method of punishment for both sexes. And of course Hamas suports stoning gays to death). Hitler consigned women to a subordinate “breeder” role for the most part but did not mandate their mutilation and murder as women if they sought an independent existence. Unless of course they were Jews.

So that’s another difference.

–FDR called for the “unconditional surrender” of Hitler and the Nazis. The UN, and international human rights organizations call for “proportionality” in the treatment of the Nazi-like murderers of Hamas which translates, apparently to using only enough force so that Hamas can keep on firing rockets at Jews at the same rate as before, a situation they found acceptable as testified to by their silence and inaction.

So that’s a big difference.

–The Allies in World War II did not care about causing civilian casualties in the course of seeking the defeat of the Nazi empire. In fact they thought the Nazi regime, busily engaged in genocide and the German people who supported him did not deserve especially “humane” or “proportional” treatment. The Israelis today go to great, even self-destructive lengths to avoid civilian casualties in trying to combat those who seek their extermination, despite the fact that Hamas is a self-proclaimed genocidal organization.

So that’s another difference.

-Liberals and liberal Jews (I’m one myself) used to think of theselves as anti-fascists and internationalists. They would be horrifed by the idea of supporting the goals of a Nazi-like party such as Hamas. Liberals and liberal Jews almost without exception supported the use of force to cause the unconditional surrender of Hitler and the Nazis. Some – not all – contemporary American liberals and some liberal Jews support the maintenance of the Nazi-like theological fascists of Hamas, who support the beheading of women and the stoning of gays, in power, rather than use force to oust them. They pat themselves on the back for being brave dissenters in their defense of the plight of a fascist genocidal party.

Presumably then these “liberals” would have been out in the streets in the ’30s demonstrating in support of Hitler’s demands for the Sudeten Deutsch against the Czechs despite the fact that the irredentists among the Sudeten Deutsch were mainly Nazis. Germany’s land was stolen after all.

So that’s a big difference too. (and perhas a reason the current Czech government supports the state of Israel.) But imagine, liberals serving as the defenders of the continuing rule of a Nazi-like party more extreme than Hitler’s! (Talk about “shtetl police”)

–This one is more complex. The people of Germany supported Hitler, yet many still claim the Germans didn’t really know what he was doing to the Jews, gays, gypsies or his plans for other ethnic minorities. Or they say that they suppported Hitler for other reasons. Some believe the German people shouldn’t be held accountable for Hitler’s crimes, some think it’s naive to believe they didn’t know and shouldn’t be held responsible. The people of Gaza voted Hamas in by a larger percentage than Hitler ever got. They knew that the Hamas charter called for genocide and supported Hamas attempts to kill as many Jews as they could.

Should they–and the Americans who believe in “even-handed” treatment of a pro-genocide party be held responsible for Hamas and what Hamas has brought upon the land, the way some believe the German people should be held responsible for the destruction Hitler brought upon Germany? Should the German people who supported Hitler have been treated with the “proportionality” we are supposed to reserve for the Gazan people who support Hamas?

I don’t know the answers to these difficult questions. I just wanted to clarify things so no one was making any false analogies between Hamas and Hitler and ignoring the fact that Hamas was more extreme than the Nazis.

I hope to see this mentioned in news reports and commentaries on the current situation.

I’m not holding my breath.

But you probably won't care because you are just an anti-Semite.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: