Who do you think Israel should belong to?

Show all answers

Ali Salamat

What is Israel ?!!

Do you mean squatted Palestine ?

Galahad

"israel" is a fraudulent state the legitimacy of which was purchased via bribery to key UN officials as jewish historian Benny Morris recently revealed. It does not exist in any real ethical sense. What you are talking about is Palestine - currently occupied by wealthy Europeans - and obviously Palestine has a right to political self-determination.

John E

Definitely the Palestinians.
So the rest of the World would enjoy some peace for once in the Middle East.
Greetings

Zeno

One state,with a Palestinian right of return. This is currently the view with most progressives,zionist colonization of the WB having reached the point where a two-state solution is impractical. However,the zionists will never agree to a multicultural society so I would have to favor an anti-colonial revolution on the part of the Palestinians,and I say that with keen regret; I simply see no other alternative to the continuing slow-motion annihilation of a people.

Relations

since the jews never had a place for 2000 how can israel be their home all of a sudden ?

jews should live in nyc.
arabs in middle east

Johnnydairishfella

As an Irish republican, i support Palestine, and the Arab countries. I am very anti-Israel, but not anti-Jew. The middle east conflict, is alot like the Anglo-Irish conflict, the tyrant on both occasions being Britain and Israel (funily enough they are both allies), and the countries affected are the Irish Republic and northern Ireland, and Palestine. By many worldwide revolutionary's and rebels, this is know as the 'One Struggle' movement, and it is also compared to the Basque region, and Columbia.

Israel may have a claim to ancient land of the jews, but seeming that the Islamic Palestinians have been there the longest, and the most recent.

I also support Palestine, because Israel, racially discriminates them. The Big wall (hmm, reminds me of northern Ireland) is an example. Also, they make the Arabs live in squalor, a bit like south Africa that, separating the blacks from the whites; and alot like northern Ireland, separating the Irish Nationalist Catholics, and the British Unionist Protestants. I'm not a racist nor A fascist, i am actually anti of the both, but i think that Israel are ignorant and a waste of space. The American Government send more aid to Israel, that to the whole continent of Africa.

But, fellow comrades, and foes, not every Jew is Israeli.

here's some useful facts, i bet none of you new, wll some of you:

-That yearly US aid to Israel exceeds the aid the US grants to the whole African continent?

-That Israel blew up an American diplomatic facility in Egypt and attacked a U.S. ship in international waters, killing 33 and wounding 177 American sailors?

-Palestinian refugees make up the largest portion of the refugee population in the world?

-That today's Israel sits on the former sites of more than 400 now-vanished Palestinian villages, and that the Israeli's re-named almost every physical site in the country to cover up the traces?

-That Sharon's coalition government includes a party Molodet: which advocates expelling all Palestinians from the occupied territories?

-That Israel has for decades routinely sent assassins in to other countries to kill its political enemies?

-That Palestinian license plates in Israel are colour coded to distinguish Jews from non-Jews?

-That Israel is the only country in the Middle East that refuses to sign the nuclear non-proliferation treaty and bars international inspections from its sites?

-That the United States awards Israel $5 billion in aid each year?

-That Israel stands in defiance of 69 United Nations Security Council Resolutions?

and also,
'In 1982, the PLO relocated to Tunis after it was driven out of Lebanon by Israel during Israel's six-month invasion of Lebanon. It remained active in Lebanon, but not to the same extent as before 1982.

On 1 October 1985, in Operation Wooden Leg, Israeli Air Force F-15s bombed the PLO's Tunis headquarters, killing more than 60 people.'

Jurgen

Your terminology is biased; today's academics use the term "Israel-Palestine". My feeling is there was no plebiscite in 1948 to no self-determination was exercised and the "jewish" atheists who flocked in after 1920 only amounted to 9% of the population. In any event,those "settlers" in the WB will not be removed so the izzies pretty much canceled out the two-sate concept. And they will never accept a single state with power-sharing. Hence,if the Pals don't wish to continue being slowly liquidated then they will have to regain their homeland. My answer: One Palestine for the Palestinians.

Maya

One state,with a Palestinian right of return. The zionist regime has ruined any possibility of a two-state solution.

Bahira

Your"israel" has been known as Palestine since at least 500 B.C. and it belongs to it's people: the Palestinians.

drtantan

ONE STATE FOR ALL
PALESTINIAN AND ISRAEL IAN

Saeqeh

PALESTINE IS FOR PALESTINE.

Bosco

It is still Palestine and it will always be Palestine and in the aftermath of the coming revolution it will again be Palestine. To answer: Palestine - "Israel" as you still call it - belongs to the Palestinians,not a pack of religious zealots and wealthy land-grabbers.

Nada

Palestine belongs to muslims.

Brynn

The two-state solution is dead,the settlements and carving up the WB into Bantustans ruined that prospect. And the izzies will never agree to a one-state solution as proffered by Abunimah and Virginia Tilley. So that only leaves one option if the Pals are to survive: to take back their countrty,by whatever means. I would recommend the same approach the Vietnamese used against the French and later the Americans.

killingcraz

of course to the palestinians. let me go all of a sudden and pay for land in the middle of the effin outback in australia and form my own country and start screaming 'god gave it to me' and kick and kill the people living there for more than 1000 years...oh wait white pple did it in australia already..

there is no country called israel. bloody white jews get their asses back 2 germany and russia, and mizrachi/shephardim back to morroco and spain..oh wait, europe doesn't want them either.

don't say how ur born in israel and u r israeli...palestinians born in israel and got kicked out...

mirzhila

i think israel should belong to every body that like her,but i think israel is better that change her area because in this area always we heard she has conflict and war with her neighbours and she had never peace in that area .their neighbours are historycal countries and israel has only 70-80 years old.

proud palestinian muslimah!!!

there's no such thing as israel...you are talking about palestine..and of course palestine belonged to the palestinians before, and it belongs to them now...and it will always belong to the palestinians....long live palestine:D

Layla

To the Palestinians... The jews lived in Germany before, now that Hitler isnt killing them anymore cus he's gone, they should go back to Germany and stop killing innocent people and bulldozing their homes with tanks and then laugh at them when they throw stones...

helpinggene

Israel Solution - Share the State
Palestines, Jews, and Christians have been there a long time. They need to make it one state for all parties and immigrants to live in. They all can be independent and share the same government. Times have changed they all need to agree on a new set of laws and respect each otherā€™s culture. Have common laws for all sides and have a representative for each culture to have community forums. They also need to agree on a universal currency or use money already in place. That state should no longer be divided to maintain peace in the land. The main leader should be impartial to all religions.

The Citzens of the State
All religions have the golden rule and they all love God. When used properly all religions are the same. Prophets show us how to love God and his people using the golden rule.

What is not a religion is those that do not know how to use the golden rule. God disciplines these abusive people on earth and in heaven. Humans on the other hand need to educate these people on the golden rule and set the right example.

Religious laws are all different but instead of making laws do more preventive type of measures. Have common laws which take people to jail or pose fines. Laws should prevent people from doing crimes by not giving them the opportunity or mindset to do it in the first place. Put the RDIF chip in those that break the law to keep crime and the prison population down. Put the RDIF chips in all of the goods to prevent stealing.

MaCeDonIan PhaLanX

To Jews and everybody that lives there!

Should the US belong to the Brazilians? should Italy belong to the French?
Israel should belong to the Israelis ,who else?

Most of the Israeli Arabs(about 1.3 million) in fact would prefer to live in a Jewish state than in Syria or Jordan for example.they enjoy the democracy(have Arab politicians in the Knesset who bash Israel from inside, would it be tolerated in Syria for example?),the women don't work and get fat check from welfare ,the men get nice unemployment money every month,enjoy great universities .what's there not to like?
These are just few of the reasons why Israel is so much better than our neighbors..

Israeli's

Samsooma The Madruba

Israel belongs to the Jews/Israelis, there is still some debate as to whom the west bank and gaza belong to, but Israel, no one questions whom the country belongs to, it's like I ask you who should the USA belong to, Mexico Indians or to Americans, and then come up with, I believe in the three state rule. What about you?

Vinita

Israel should belong to Israelis,just like any other country should belong to its own people.

Shay p

Israel is, it belongs to me and mine, it will never belong to anyone but Israel.

There are 194 countries in the world today. Israel has no diplomatic relations with 34 countries, It is not recognized by 26 of them and the partially recognized Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic.III

Dr. Cox

i believe the jews should run it so theres no problems (terrorism)

Dymanic Investigator

Jewish people.

shunra

Israel is and should belong to the Israelis.

Loco G

Israel should and will belong to the rightful owners.
The Jews.

Canute

Jordan is Palestine.

Jews to Israel, Arabs to Arabia.

Evul Bunneh !

Two state solution is the right way.
sure each side can go on and on and on about how he should have the whole land, but it can be divided, the arabs will get west bank and gaza, and run their own state, Israel should not care about them what so ever, once they'll have their own state.
if they will flourish, good for them, but if they fail running their own state, its their problem.

Plus If the future Palestine state, will be hostile to Israel in the future, such as Hamas will take over the country and attacks Israel, Israel will respond with full force, and wont mercy them, because being attacked by a state is not the same as being attacked but terror organizations with no country.
Hopefully that wont happen and we can live in peace.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: