Why do the Palestinians really collectively punish all the population of southern Israel ?

Show all answers

Shay p

By building the wall we eliminated their ability to hit us with car bombs and suicide bombers, now the Palsetinans use a missile war to replace the face to face terrorist war.

This was the reason for the last war on the Gaza, 5000 qassams sent before we really retaliated.

Kimimela-PRO ISRAEL AND PROUD

Because now israel has tighter control on palastinian borders and not as many terrorists can get through to blow them selves up in jerusalem cafes or tel aviv night clubs.

These are people that want to wipe israel off the map, push all jews into the sea, glorify death and suicide, encourage their children to rant against jews and strap bombs to themselves, dress up babies like suicide bombers and dance in the street everytime an israeli or jew is killed.

These people are sub human, they are worse than animals... their tactics in southern gaza dont surprise me ... they want us all dead and they wont stop trying until someone stopps them first

dandyl

The Palestinian terrorist group don't have any conscious ,they are cowards, there main objective is to kill and destroy as many Israeli citizens as possible, and to eliminate Israel off the world map.Hamas consistently judges the success of their attacks by the number of Israelis they kill ā€“ men, women, children. Hamas does not even try to attack military targets; their rockets are directed toward towns, cities and farms rather than military bases. The group's rockets land on playgrounds, apartment buildings, public parks, schools and private homes.

Hamas terrorists choose not to expose themselves by firing these weapons from open areas. They construct launch pads in densely populated regions in Gaza, using the local Palestinian population as a shield because they do not care if their fellow Palestinians are killed by their own misfiring rockets (as frequently occurs) or by retaliatory strikes by Israel. The leaders of Hamas, like their ideological soulmates in Hezbollah, actually prefer that Israel hits back because they know that if civilians inadvertently are casualties, the international community will blame the Israelis.

edit...to goat, I have never said that the Palestinians do not exist, what I have said is that Palestine does not exist, pay attention to what people write

Greenie M

the real problem is, now they have Gaza all for themselves but they haven't any plans to build up their economy even with the enormous amounts of aid they got.
it is sad to admit, but muslim countries with no natural resources (oil i mean:) )are poor and mainly depend on foreign aid.
what these people know well, is fight and bring many children to this world - apparently without plans how to raise them.
to all their economics and social problems their leaders say:
it's because the zionists. destroy them and all'll be well.
...and they naively think that after they destroyed all the "zionists" their life will be paradise on earth.

Shadi

With the home made rockets? Are you sure you are making sense by using this "collective punishment" thing, or you are just saying that because zionist state is committing that crime against civilian population of Gaza?

kismet

Hamas uses collective punishment simply because they do not want Israel to exist. It is in their charter!

I often wonder why they use their own people as human shields and why they launch their cowardly attacks from mosques, schools, zoos, hospitals, and apartment buildings:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTu-AUE9ycs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfTr609whl8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tk5CBTgI030

The First Dragon

Punishment is not the main purpose of Palestinians who shoot rockets into Israel, or do suicide bombings.
Their main purpose is to overthrow the state of Israel. Both Hamas and Fatah take the position that Israel has no right to exist; the land should be governed by Muslim Arabs.
The purpose of terrorist attacks is to scare the population into giving up without a fight. The purpose of attacks on Israel is to drive the Jews out of the land, or kill them. I'm not making this up. The movement started right after the fall of the Ottoman Empire in WWI, to remove or kill all Jews in the British Mandate of Palestine, which included what are now Jordan and Israel, as well as the lands now called Palestinian. Under Ottoman rule, Jews had second-class dhimmi status, and apparently were tolerated better in that position.
One thing I am not clear on: Why are the jihadis targeting Australia for terrorism? "They do the same to our lands" doesn't make much sense to me, because it is inaccurate as far as I know.
I notice that the US is included in this threat, and I know that the US is called the Great Satan, so I guess that's a good motive. I live in California, and we too have annual wildfires, sometimes extremely destructive. I don't quite see them as a terror weapon though, because for one thing we have always had them, and for another thing they don't come into the high-population areas, of course. Summer is approaching in a few months, and the last few years have been pretty dry, so wildfires will not be a surprise.
It sounds like the jihadis enjoy destruction just for the sake of it....

It isn't punishment.
As much as the Pal supporters yell genocide the only one actually wanting it is Hamas.
They want all Jews dead and the land salted.

SARA

The IDF has nukes!!
Super Tanks, Fighter Jets, Ships, and Advanced guns , Submarines etc...
They have a very advanced Army while hamas only have homemade bombs and rockets made of gunpowder, take a look at Gaza city...Its a real tragedy.

So please view the whole case before making conclusion

Lupines supports GEERT WILDERS

The Palestinians collectively punish because they have issues with living next door to Jewish people. It's been so evident in all their behavior with Jewish people living in Muslim dominated lands where Jewish people were subjected to various forms of terror by the extremist populace in those states. The Palestinians themselves are the most extremist out of the bunch, as they were sent from other Arab lands and migrated there to specifically fight Israel and when they lost they created this new Palestinian people, an extremist movement to continuet the fight. After 100 years they've bred their terror exponentially with their children and it has gone "unchecked" by Western powers. The extremist Muslims allied up with Hitler, but while allied forces "checkmated" Hitler, the Muslims that allied up with Hitler weren't even "checked." Did you know that Muslims raised SS troops and made concentration camps in Muslim dominated lands? yes they did and that little known fact that there are Muslims that hate Jewish people and the worst of the worst are the Palestinians themselves goes widely unrecognized. They launched a political campaign to make it "about land" but it's really about another issue. They don't want peace with Israel, they don't want land, they want pieces of Israel, the Jewish state, to chizel away at it one terror incident at a time. They only collectively punish Southern Israel by the way, because their rockets don't reach farther into Israel, and the border wall and fencing only keeps them from going into Israel. Otherwise, they'd just collectively punish everybody. That is their terrorist mentality.

"The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. For tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa. While as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." -- PLO Executive Committee member Zuhayr Muhsin, March 31, 1977, interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw."

Hamas In Their Own Voices
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i08L09V0_sg
Rome Will be Conquered, [and we will] spread thru Europe in its entirety and the two Americas -- Yunis Al-Astal, Hamas MP & Cleric, Hamas TV 4/13/08
The Islamic nation is rising and awakening and will regain leadership of the world... Death to America, Death to Israel -- Khaled Mashal, Hamas Leader while in Qatar 2/3/06
Children's Hamas television saying: We will wipe out the people of Zion and not leave a single one of them. Children in suicide bombing vests and ak-47s. Hamas TV & Hezbollah TV
America and Israel will be annihilated and kill them all down to the very last one. -- Sheik Ahmad Bahr, Palestinian Leglislative Council, Acting Speaker Iran TV, 6/15/07
As Muslims, our blood vengeance against them will only subside with their annihilation. -- Wael Al-Zarad, Hamas Cleric, Hamas TV 3/25/08
The annihilation of the Jews is one of the most splendid blessings for Palestine. -- Muhsen Abu 'Ita, Hamas Cleric, Hamas TV 10/15/08

Missile and Mortar Attacks on Israel Pass 10,000 Mark
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/128897

60% of the Palestinian population now wants to elect someone, Marwan Barghouti, who is serving 5 lifetime sentences for cold blooded murder.
Haniyeh/Abbas/Barghouti
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/130350

"I ask you: This [Palestinian] people, which has made all these sacrifices... The [Palestinian] mother is unparalleled throughout history. She grabs her son and says to him: Off you go, on a martyrdom operation. When the second son comes, she says: Off you go, too, and then the third son, and the fourth. A [Palestinian] girl, in the prime of life, thinking of getting married, dons an explosive belt and plunges into the Israelis. This people, from the children to the elderly...http://www.memritv.org/clip/en/0/0/0/0/0/0/1775.htm

"The Oslo Accords were a trojan horse; the strategic goal is the liberation of Palestine from [the Jordan] river to [the Med] Sea." Faysal Al Husseini PA Minister for Jerusalem Affairs, 24June2001 Al-Arabi Daily Newspaper

59% of Palestinians support the armed struggle against Israel even after receiving statehood with East Jerusalem as their capital. PCPO 2003 margin +/- 4%

72% of children from Gaza expressed hopes of becoming suicide martyrs. Sout Al-Nissa (voice of the woman) Al-Ayyam 24Jan2001

Niky

The israeli want nothing but peace. When the un broke the land into israel and Palestine the israelis built their their govt and society while the hama and Palestinians have devoted their life to kill the israelis. They didn't bother to build their society instead they they decided it's easier to destroy than build.

ā�

Gaza terrorists will utilize any form of terrorism to achieve their aims, the destruction of Israel.

Local Machine

OK, I am older and you are just a kid, so let me correct your pretty little question, Jr.
It's
Why do the jews really collectively punish all the poor Palestine population of southern Israel ?

Gazza. Does this word ring any bells? huh?

Aw! shucks!
Lookie here son. Can you spot 10 differences?
http://pakalert.files.wordpress.com/2009/01/naziasmvszionismpy7_2009-01-09-20-58-54-296.jpg

I just hope that you did not try to fool us Camel Person

The Machine

Will Smith

Because they have to know they are in the wrong place, and there are other people suffering because of them and their government.
You are very zooming in, make zoom out to see the whole picture.

One more thing, if you call a stuffed-with-powder pipes that can't be aimed, a punishment for a whole population, what do you call the entire blockade on Gaza, the racist wall, the F16's air strikes on civil areas, the humiliating checkpoints ....?

G.O.A.T - sigur

surely you mean hamas, not Palestinians unless you can prove every single Palestinian living in Gaza Israel and the west bank. are in some way collectively punishing Israeli people living in southern Israel.
give me a link for this.....
this collective punishment works both way Israel refusing to let in medical supplies and basic aid. that is also seen as a way of collectively punishing gazans.holding out on peace talks of opening the border crossing because of one captured solider. putting one soldier's life above the millions of gazans is also collectively punishing.

that does not make it OK for what hamas does, but to only blame one side when both are clearly wrong. is your peoples problem until you both own up. and stop blaming each other. everything you do and say we all be labeled propaganda by each other.

comrade otto

for the same reason israel uses 11 year olds as human shields

http://haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1073243.html

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: