Why doesn't the US move the Israeli population to the USA instead of leaving them among enemies in Palestine

Show all answers

samy n

it is betterthat every one return back to his origin country,,,,and work for development of this country as all israeilies came from diffrent countries lifting thir friends and works

king of the Jungle

the Jews can have New York, the largest Jewish populated state in the USA

tamarindwalk

Because they are not our problem.

We didn't move the Cambodians to the U.S. when the Khmer Rouge came along. Why would we owe someone else such special treatment?

HopelessZ00

Well, if all the Palestinians are coming to Canada , and all the Israelis go to the States. The war in the holy land would stop! No more people would be there! Perhaps then it would truly be the holy land where all faiths could visit and pray to God and peace would be found. (Crazy theory i know) Bottom line somehow, someway we all have to start thinking about the next generation. Life is so short to waste it on fighting and hating. When are Muslims, Christians and Jews going to wake up and realize this? And learn to live together? One day either way peace will come. Cheers!

mark

Well the Israeli are getting free money to stay where they are.
Israel receive more than 20 billions $ each year from American taxpayers without their consent: 3.7B$ from the Congress Foreign Aid Program, 10B$ Free Loans Guarantee, and 6 to 10 B$ from USA Tax System Loophole as Charity money deducted from American JEWS Tax's to be sent to illegal Israeli Settlements.

the kid next door

not even america wants them on there land.

Caroline J

The US are extraordinarily concerned with Israel, moreso than any other country in the world. The question is why.

It is because of the US's high level of belief in the Bible and their concern for Israel to return to the Holy Land in order to make Biblical prophecy come true. If the US was not so religious, they would have this belief. They will never move them into the US because it would guarantee that Israel would never end up back in the Holy Land.

DlCK Chenney

Israel already consider a 51 states of United Stated by forced.
Every yrs. u.s force to give israel 8 billion dollars in aid.
With that money they funnel back to u.s use for political gains
such as: lobby for bills that favorite israel
bills ......forgiven loan
bills.......increase loan
bills.......more aid
bills.......declared all Arabs hated jews terrorism
bills.......go to war with iraq
bills.......calling iran to give up nuclear power, only israel can have it
And all kind of bills that cost u.s tax payers in billion dollars in the name of israel ...or for real.

.....the money continue funnel back to u.s toward organization such as AIPAC .... give loan to other jewish business buying and complete control of u.s media from tv, radio, news paper and hollywood. When the last time you hear any bad things about israel on tv.....all cover up ...only sympathy and lies.
but... alot about palestine throwing rocks at innocent jews.

...money pour in to u.s museum and foundation keep the lies alive ....from holocaust to con camp and anne frank and so on.

When the last time you see a rabbi working as construction workers eh. or plumbing ...

There our taxes money get stolen and use to feed the lies and the greedy.

[ ImpaKt ]

Hands down!! Great Que.

Ive always say the same thing.

Considering that, papa US's granting the billions of dollars to Zions every month along with
other aids i might add,
plus, US showing its compassion
to wards Zions! when Zions
hit the high mark of slaughtering poor and innocent Palestinians!!? or rallying with their bulldozers
on their homes, ALSO
considering the fact that, this conflict will never, ever goes aways unless Zions move out and give the stolen land back,

SO............why OH why US won't give the Arizona desert to these Zions thus they could call it ''''Israzona''' for i care, then world will at last have peace and the poor Palestinians could start a normal, humane life as they deserve.

Smeagol AM

Because the Jews are the invaders in this situation. They have no right to this land, and yet more and more of them come in there pushing the original Palestinian inhabitants out.

The Jews in that region have earned everything they get, they are again the INVADERS, not the Palestinians.

They left that region 2000 years ago. It is only because the Jews are powerful financially that they get any support from the US or EU, take away their money, and you take away their power, and the Jews are only rich because the Catholic church banned usury amongst Catholics, leaving Jews in the perfect position to exploit the masses of Europe by becoming moneylenders.

Brynn

Europeans and Americans devised the so-called jewish State as a dumpsite for their unwanted elements.

Bosco

This is called hypocrisy. They would never relinquish their own territory. They would never tolerate people's homes being bulldozed because they aren't "jewish". They will never give up New England for a "jewish' homeland on grounds that It Was Never a Country In It's Own Right.
They would never permit jews to fly down over a street and kill forty people with a hellfire missile.

Galahad

I've the matter some thought,and I think Unalaska would be perfect for them.

Kourtney M

Why would we want to bring in that many more immigrants to worry about? How would that save the US money. Plus what kind of problems will we be creating by doing that? The US will only be creating more problems finically and we would be creating more problems nationally and internationally by doing that.

The First Dragon

Well, the US doesn't own the Israeli people and therefore cannot move them wherever it chooses.
The Israelis have put a lot of their own blood, sweat, and tears into building their country, so most of them want to stay.
The US has already benefited a lot from the Jews that have immigrated or been born here. Jews were part of the Revolutionary War, and they have been part of the US ever since. We are willing to share the benefits of Jewish religion and culture with the rest of the world too.
But take notice, we cannot have a Jewish State here, any more than we can have and Islamic State. The US Constitution forbids the "establishment of religion," and religion has thrived here as a result.

wars and rumors of wars

Americans and Israelis already benefit one another as it is. Neither country has a history of running from their enemies, so this is not a likely option.

Humble E.

Because the Israelis want to stay there.

unforgettable_1

I believe the Israelis prefer to stay in what is their homeland. They want to stay near their religous sites also. People don't like being uprooted and moved around the world for the benefit of anyone.

Lisa K

Move the Israelis? What right would this country have to move any population from their own country to this one?

Leave the Israelis where they are, it's one of the safest, most beautiful countries I have ever seen. One couldn't walk around an arab country with the freedom and security as people do in Israel.

peace lover

why don't the arabs help their brothers and sisters and move the "palestinians" out of refugee camps and back into jordan or egypt or whereever.

Claymore Thomas III

You gotta be kidding me buddy!
They are all just fine where they are at right now, OK?
Don't you get any crazy ideas, you hear?
Thomas.

lemon_lorrain

According to the Question, the U.S. is supposed to allow a state for each racial or religious group--so, there would be Cuban, Italian. Irish, Indian, Polish, Chinese, Spanish, Jewish, etc. STATES comprising the U.S. But the world already has Cuba, Italy, Ireland, India, Poland, China, Spain, and Israel, etc. And there would of course have to be an Arab state...or, would the Palestinians demand their own state because they are 'different' from Jordan, Syria, Saudi Arabia, and Iraq which all speak the same language and have the same religion!

Shadow

besides the historical and patriotic values of the Israelites..do you really believe that the U.S. could fund and home that massive kind of immigration? Even if THAT was a possibility, then it would be giving into the demands of the enemies. It means that the Palestians would win, and that that Israel would give up their land. No true believer of the their cause would stand for that.

Hatikvah JPA

Better idea. Why doesn't the infamous international community (who blames Israel for every problem) RESETTLE those poor refugees in their own countries!

Are Palestinians the first refugee population in history? Hardly. But they are surely the first refugees who, as a group, have categorically RESISTED RESETTLEMENT, instead living for decades as wards of the international community. Indeed, in Gaza today, years after Israel renounced any territorial claims, there continue to be refugee camps. Why? Why -- other than to serve as incubators for hatred that produce recruits bent on martyrdom and mayhem -- are there Palestinian refugee camps in Palestinian territory?
http://www.aish.com/jewishissues/middleeast/Nothing_Short_of_a_Miracle.asp

The trust deficit is exacerbated by the fact that after Israel quit the Gaza Strip in 2005, Palestinians, instead of building Singapore there, built Somalia and focused not on how to make microchips, but on how to make rockets to hit Israel. Thomas Friedman
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/04/opinion/04friedman.html?em&ex=1212811200&en=1ca1f27e6a40c673&ei=5070
.

sux_2b_ewe

Because it has to do the the land they are in being there historical homeland. Bringing them anywhere else is denying them of their homeland in the Israeli's eyes.

dandyl

israel belongs to the jewish people, the jews have always had enemies, no matter where they will live there will always be hatred towards them.
In the late 19th century, the rise of religious and racist anti-Semitism led to a resurgence of pogroms in Russia and Eastern Europe, shattering promises of equality and tolerance. This stimulated Jewish immigration to Palestine from Europe.

Simultaneously, a wave of Jews immigrated to Palestine from Yemen, Morocco, Iraq and Turkey. These Jews were unaware of Theodor Herzl's political Zionism or of European pogroms. They were motivated by the centuries-old dream of the â€œReturn to Zionâ€ and a fear of intolerance. Upon hearing that the gates of Palestine were open, they braved the hardships of travel and went to the Land of Israel.

The Zionist ideal of a return to Israel has profound religious roots. Many Jewish prayers speak of Jerusalem, Zion and the Land of Israel. The injunction not to forget Jerusalem, the site of the Temple, is a major tenet of Judaism. The Hebrew language, the Torah, laws in the Talmud, the Jewish calendar and Jewish holidays and festivals all originated in Israel and revolve around its seasons and conditions. Jews pray toward Jerusalem and recite the words â€œnext year in Jerusalemâ€ every Passover. Jewish religion, culture and history make clear that it is only in the land of Israel that the Jewish commonwealth can be built.

In 1897, Jewish leaders formally organized the Zionist political movement, calling for the restoration of the Jewish national home in Palestine, where Jews could find sanctuary and self-determination, and work for the renascence of their civilization and culture.

SMILE 2 ME

once again little girl.................... Israel is and always will be the land of the Jews with Jerusalem as its undivided capital for ever.

I suppose you would want them on Reservations. That would mean more casinos. That would mean more poor Americans, whom I guess would be considered Native American then.
It would be nice if you tried harder to make some sense sometimes without being overly insulting. It ruins your humor.

dmaud56

There is mistrust among Jews regarding all "goy" populations, especially European, so some feel safer in Israel, terrorism and all. Also, you keep them there, you have an active testing ground for weapons of war. Every time a new weapon is developed, it is always battle tested in Israel first. One thing is to design a jet that hypothetically can shoot down 20 migs in 5 minutes, actual air combat however, is something else, or even something as simple as a bombing run.

There are also cost issues and besides, here is a question for YOU, if you happen to be Muslim.

Even if all Jews left "Palestine," if Islam took over the world what then?

Will you say Jews don't belong here, or there, or anywhere, or perhaps build a space ship and blow us off the planet?

Given the pattern among Arabs you do not seem poised to ever stop.

The ashkenazi are watered down tyrants, who are more like white barbarians than actual semites. Their men are arrogant and cowardly, and their women, like all white women are materialistic whores.

My own people, the Iraqi Jews, are nearly extinct, and all that remains of pure Hebrews, Hebrews with absolutely no European admixture, live as Muslims in Saudi Arabia, imprisoned both by a police state and a messed up religion.

The Hebrews as a group of people, true, SEMITIC Jews, semitic, as a tribe separate from all other semites, Hebrew, like the ancient Hebrews of the bible, we are facing extinction, and those ashkenazi bastards are lying to the world calling us "Arabs" or saying we don't even exist at all. An ashkenazi brat even destroyed my family and she has never apologized, and she never will apologize, because she is just a white barbarian whore.

Someday though, the Messiah will break the backs of both Arabs, and the west.

alan m

As their name suggests they belong to Israel. Far better for the enemies to move to Usa in some desert region away from the world.

alphamaletank

Yea because America needs more immigrants here.Don't worry though if dumb *** Obama gets elected he will fix everything.Because raising taxes has done so much to help our country already.Every business owner is going to take it up the *** if that man gets elected.

**** Obama.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: