Why has no other arab country offered the Palestinians a place of refuge ?

Show all answers

Irit

no other country wants them!!!!!

Paliâ™¥Muslimah

What Ghalahad said, and most of Jordan is Palestinian Refugees, including me, and my family!

Galahad

There are now an estimated 5 million diaspora Palestinians living throughout the Arab world. Your question is based on a patently false premise which originates with increasingly stale zionist propaganda. Jordan,to cite merely one example, itself is now ethnically a Palestinian-majority country.

Zeno

Galahad is correct. There are many millions of diasporic Palestinians living throughout the Arab states. Since your "question" presupposes that this is not so,it isn't actually a question,just a statement,and a false one at that.

By the way,the King of Jordan is married to a Palestinian. You seem either very ignorant or perhaps merely a victim of "jewish" propaganda.

It should also be noted that the U.S. has given 7 million Jews "a place of refuge". That is more than half the Jews on earth,and there are no pogroms or death death camps. The U.S. is also the sole reason why this monstrous entity devouring Palestine is able to exist.

John E

My dear friend, I believe it's the Palestinians that do not want that.
They, alone will succeed without any outside help.
These people are going to be the leaders of all of the Arab world in the very near future.
Mark my words.
The Jews (and American Lobby Jews) are dealing with a very determined and decisive nation, that cannot be intimidated nor corrupted like so many Arab nations in the past.
I have complete faith in those brave Palestinians.
With their courage and strong will they have no chance but to succeed in taking back their country.
Greetings

naserq22

you complain of deleting i my self as palestinian
i do not find you breaking any rules with this question
on the contrary if the reason behind it is to know and to understand it is really worth to answer you
if you look to wars these days on the map of the world you will see civilians refuge to some neighboring countries as you see in Iraq you will see Iraqi es refuges mostly to Iran .Jordan>Syria few to Lebanon only few to Saudi and other rich oil countries
you may take the example of Afghanistan and you will see the same as well
the same applies to Palestinians
you ought to admit here in those countries in wars once war is stopped all refugees are back home notice the 33 days war in lebanon in the day 34 all refugees went back home
so actually two facts are born here
1 the Arabs welcomed the refugees from palestine as a previous answerer has explained so you see the direct neighboring countries has opened the homes for palestinians
you must know that Jordan has the largest borders with palestine so they absorbed the highest numbers then syria lebanon egypt
2 once any war ends the refugees problems must be ended
jordan went to a treaty with israel but they did not solve the problem of refugees neither or
so that gives the impression that state of war is still until palestinians decide and acknowledge the right of return is fulfilled

Misty Blue

Galahad gave you the answer but to add to that can I just say do you seriously think if Palestinians had all fled in to surrounding Arab lands they would get to come back one day.Israel would have taken hold completely and would never have let go.

One T

Deleted Answer: What reason would they have to blame the Jews if they did? If they keep them poor, unemployed and uneducated while brain washing them with fairy tails about Jewish Monsters they keep them violent and serve their interests. They care more about hurting the Jews than helping their brothers.

~Sawyer

The Arabs living in Israel find a greater economy when Israel runs things. The surrounding Arab nations are not willing to share amongst their own family, so they figure those in Israel can live off the Israeli government...while claiming they are displaced.
I have repeatedly asked why Jordan, Egypt or any of the other Arab nations do not give up a piece of their land so these poor, mistreated Arab Israelis can have somewhere to live.

Amy W

If you ran a country, would you want to offer them refuge? A lot went to Jordan, but then Arafat tried to have King Hussein killed. Besides, if they don't have any place to go, it is better anti-Israel PR.

Compare that to how Israel took in all the Jewish refugees from Arab countries in 1948-1949!

(BTW, I have had a number of questions deleted, even though they didn't break any rules. One question asked about Jews reading psalms on Israel's Independence Day! I challenged that one and it was restored. I think if someone ojjects it is automatically deleted.)

Isis

Yes, Galahad is right we do have millions of Palestinian refugees. Besides saying that the majority have high amounts of land so what?? Palestine belongs to the Palestinians why should they give up their homeland to some greedy people who are taking something that doesn't belong to them?? Zionists have to face the fact that they are sitting in someone elses' home and if anyone is to leave that it should be them and not the Palestinians.
Misty Blue is right once the Palestinians leave they are not allowed to go back.

My question to you is why do you kill the Palestinians and take a land that's not yours in the first place??

peace lover

they've always used the so called palestinians as pawns in their fight against israel. the arabs don't care about the palestinians and never did.

there are no palestinian refugee camps in israel, but jordan, lebanon and others still have large refugee camps of palestinians, they are run by the UN and the arab countries won't let the palestinians out, won't let them work, won't do anything for them.

another example of how it's not about palestine or occupation or any of those lies, it's just their hatred of jews.

Amazing. I thought this would be deleted early, but then what platform would the nazi's use if they did?
I wonder exactly how many of the so called Pals ever owned land anywhere and how many of them were just hired help to start with.
At this point I would figure most of the ones that ran away are dead and their children are making claims their parents and grand parents never did.

Cool Breeze

More propaganda from so-called israelis,that's all. Galahad is right.

gypsy_cat 345

Sigh. What a no-brainer; although, what would one expect from someone who doesn't have...oh, never mind.
Pal, did it ever occur to you that these "Arab countries" realize the Palestinians want THEIR land back...not somebody else's?

sjdgls

They don't want to because these arabs are pawns, pretend refugees, in the propaganda battle with Israel. There really are no refugees.

Lola

Why has no Western country offered the Jews a place of refuge?

Sarah

they wont take them in because they are viewed as a volatile population that can offset the political stability in a lot of countries.

i'm sorry if this upsets people but i am stating this from the rest of the middle east's view point NOT my own.

for example, Jordan wont take them because the ruling family already rules as a Minority and an increase in the ethnic Palestinian population in Jordan could topple the government.
However Jordan was originally created for the Palestinian people by the UK in the 1920's. see here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Jordan

there is much more to the story than this but the main idea is that a lot of the middle east does not see the Palestinian problem as their problem. i personally believe it is the entire worlds problem and we as a community need to do what we can to fix the situation. unfortunately we can not until we can get the rest of the middle east on board.

Enter Your Message or Comment

User Name:
User Email:
Post a comment: